One of the things that has me floundering is that I am not able to take the right metrics/meausrements when it comes to batteries.
For example I report on voltages - but they are open-circuit readings which are obviously not as useful or meaningful as the actual operating voltage under load.
This became pretty obvious to me when I was trying to determine the actual threshold cut-off voltage of the Dorcy 45lumen 1AA flashlight - I could only report on the open-circuit voltage before or after the runtime tests - but not during, when the battery was being used in the flashlight.
I wanted to be able to determine the operating voltage under load for the Kodak Pre-Charged and eneloop to see if there was a difference.
So I thought of a pretty simple somewhat artificial method, but should be easily controlled and reproducible -
just get a 1 ohm resistor and read the voltage when the resistor was loaded across the battery terminals.
To start this I charged one each of Kodak P-C and eneloop AA and then allowed them to rest and cool down for approx 2 hours -
Open-Circuit readings -
eneloop #1: ... 1.454V; FA=11.6A; 1.436V
Kodak P-C #1: 1.423V; FA=10.4A; 1.409V
1 ohm load readings -
ene = 1.388V @ 1.25A (= 1.735watts)
KPC = 1.336V @ 1.22A (= 1.630watts)
End of test o-c readings
ene = 1.440V
KPC = 1.412V
Under a 1 ohm load - eneloop maintained 0.052V higher than the KPC, which is about 4% higher voltage.
From open-circuit voltages (3 sets) the actual differences were 0.031V; 0.027V; 0.028V higher for eneloop - which is about 2% higher for eneloop in all 3 sets.
So this shows that not only is the voltage higher for the eneloops under the same conditions - the KPC sags more under-load than the eneloop.
For example I report on voltages - but they are open-circuit readings which are obviously not as useful or meaningful as the actual operating voltage under load.
This became pretty obvious to me when I was trying to determine the actual threshold cut-off voltage of the Dorcy 45lumen 1AA flashlight - I could only report on the open-circuit voltage before or after the runtime tests - but not during, when the battery was being used in the flashlight.
I wanted to be able to determine the operating voltage under load for the Kodak Pre-Charged and eneloop to see if there was a difference.
So I thought of a pretty simple somewhat artificial method, but should be easily controlled and reproducible -
just get a 1 ohm resistor and read the voltage when the resistor was loaded across the battery terminals.
To start this I charged one each of Kodak P-C and eneloop AA and then allowed them to rest and cool down for approx 2 hours -
Open-Circuit readings -
eneloop #1: ... 1.454V; FA=11.6A; 1.436V
Kodak P-C #1: 1.423V; FA=10.4A; 1.409V
1 ohm load readings -
ene = 1.388V @ 1.25A (= 1.735watts)
KPC = 1.336V @ 1.22A (= 1.630watts)
End of test o-c readings
ene = 1.440V
KPC = 1.412V
Under a 1 ohm load - eneloop maintained 0.052V higher than the KPC, which is about 4% higher voltage.
From open-circuit voltages (3 sets) the actual differences were 0.031V; 0.027V; 0.028V higher for eneloop - which is about 2% higher for eneloop in all 3 sets.
So this shows that not only is the voltage higher for the eneloops under the same conditions - the KPC sags more under-load than the eneloop.