your opinion

sunspot

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
2,707
Location
Graham, NC
Help!
I can't decide between two knives.
Camillus Cuda titanium nitride spear point,4" blade,fancy open flipper(?), $124

Benchmade 942, black blade and scales, AxisLock, 3.4" blade, $129

Thanks......dana
grin.gif
confused.gif
 

mikep

Enlightened
Joined
Sep 22, 2000
Messages
305
Location
IL
I wasn't crazy about the cuda opening thingy when i've played with them, and isn't the lock mechanism a locking liner? I personally find the axis lock to be 'cooler', and i believ it is much stronger. hopefully you can handle both before making your decision.
 

mikep

Enlightened
Joined
Sep 22, 2000
Messages
305
Location
IL
Re: liner lock "weakness"
I personally have never had a liner lock fail on me. I usually don't subject a knife to very rough handling, either. I'm not sure if the way they usually would fail would be the liner bending, or just getting shoved out of the way if the handle is twisted a certain way.
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
just to help you make a decision, my 'cuda opening mechanism is silky smooth and can be operated in a snap... I don't know about the different locks, I do believe the 'cuda is a liner lock, though I don't see how it could be much stronger -
 

sunspot

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
2,707
Location
Graham, NC
i have handled both types of opening things, but not these exact models. they feel different, but both good. as far as the liner lock, thats so common now as to be a standard. doing reading on the liner lock, its supposed to be greater than((----)fill in blank). whats the general gripe or safety concernon them?

......dana.....
confused.gif
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
... my (only) gripe about the 'cuda is that the blade can open with gravity only, an advantage for some, a disadvantage for others...
 

sunspot

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
2,707
Location
Graham, NC
thanks ted. i'm leaning towards the benchmade because of the shorter blade. 4" is to long in some states for carry. isn't the cuda tension owner set? still want to hear about the liner lock issue.

.....dana....
wink.gif
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
just measured my little left-handed 'cuda, the blade is 3" on the longer one it is 3 7/8" - both have a bolt in the 'hinge' that looks like it would take a hex key - I don't know if they could be tightened..
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
I see what you're saying..maybe somehow it could happen that the liner is pushed into the unlock position. I find it not possible to do just holding it my hand and twisting it..but maybe the probablity of that happening could be further reduced by filing down that portion of the liner, with the thumb serations, so it is further below the surface of the handle, (instead of flush with it, as it is on my 'cuda)?
 

Gandalf

Enlightened
Joined
Jul 3, 2001
Messages
802
Location
USA
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by mikep:
Re: liner lock "weakness"
I personally have never had a liner lock fail on me. I usually don't subject a knife to very rough handling, either. I'm not sure if the way they usually would fail would be the liner bending, or just getting shoved out of the way if the handle is twisted a certain way.
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

I copied this from the NG rec.knives:

From Rec.knives
-------------------------
Last Updated: December 1998
A well-made liner lock is a beautiful thing. The action is smooth,
the lock is very strong, and it can be opened and closed one-handed.
However, it is easy for the knifemaker to make a mistake on a liner
lock. Many common mistakes can result in the lock accidently
unlocking, and this is a serious threat to fingers. Below are some of
the tests we recommend a potential buyer try on a liner lock. Keep in
mind that many of the factory knives easily pass all the tests below,
while many knives from custom makers -- including those lauded in the
knife rags -- often don't pass. Test your knives, don't assume the
more expensive knife has the more secure lock-up!

One caveat is that the second of A.T.'s suggestions, the
"palm-on-spine" and "whack-the-spine" tests, are a bit controversial.
We both feel that a blade should never close due to palm pressure, and
a moderate whack on the spine shouldn't make a blade fold up either.
Some makes say that a knife in normal use does not ever get whacked on
the spine, so this test is not real-world. You can decide for
yourself how secure you think the lock should be.

A.T. Barr's tests:

- You don't want your blade to open except when you want it to.
Always check for a good detent ball to blade tang contact. Open your
liner lock normally and then close it very slowly. The blade *should*
snap closed the last 1/16" or so.

- Open your knife blade very slowly, until the lock engages. Do not
snap it open. You want the tension of the liner lock to just snap to
the tang of the knife. Then do two things. First turn the knife over,
and using the palm of your hand try to close the blade. It should not
close. Then strike the blade spine on the table. Not real hard, but it
needs some pressure. It should not close.

[ Note from Joe: A lot of people have been cutting themselves very
badly trying this test. Please, be sure to keep your fingers out of
the path of the blade! If you can't keep your fingers out of the way,
a reader suggested trying this test another way. Put the knife down
on a table with the blade hanging off the edge. Hold the handle down
with one side, and put pressure on the blade back. If the lock fails,
it will drop and hit the table instead of your fingers. ]

- Snap the blade open REAL FAST, then close it. If it takes a lot of
pressure to unlock the blade, walk away from that knife.

- Open the knife blade real slow, and check for any movement. Sideways
or up & down.


Great tip:
Also, if your liner lock has a sloppy lock-up, sometimes you can help
it by snapping the blade open and then half-way hard striking the
blade (try to close it) on it's tang. That will help seat the Titanium
liner to the tang of the blade. If that does not work, send it back
to the maker. Be careful when you do this. If the blade does
disengage, the blade will hit your knuckle. A number of rec.knife
readers have reported good results using this tip.


Joe Talmadge's tests:

Open knife, then thumb the lock aside (blade is still open). Wiggle
the knife back and forth. If the blade has *any* play at all, that's
a bad sign. It might just be that the pivot is too loose, so tighten
the pivot until there is no more side-to-side play, and then make sure
the action is still acceptable. Sometimes a knifemaker will have a
bad action, and then make it appear smoother by loosening the pivot
too much.

On top of that, I do the "white knuckle" test, which many makers also
fail. Making believe I'm under stress, I grab the knife in a very
firm grip, letting the flesh of my fingers sink in and around the
liner to whatever extent this happens. Now the question is: will
small movements unlock the lock (if a small movement moves the lock AT
ALL, assume it can unlock it)? If the lock is too loose or too high
relative to the handle scales, a knife that passes the other tests
might fail this. I made an expensive folder from a well-known maker
fail this way. I sent it back to him and he fixed it to my
satisfaction. That is why I like the AFCK-style handles that do not
give easy access to the lock via a cut-out -- I'd rather it be a
little harder to unlock than to unlock accidently under weird
conditions.

Bob Kaspar recommended a torque test as well, which is a test many
liner locks fail. You want to open the blade and then torque it while
applying pressure against the spine. The lock should not fail simply
because the blade is being torqued a bit. I do this test by sticking
the blade through something hard, a few layers of strong cardboard or
wood, and then torquing the blade while trying to shut it.
"Republicans Don't Kill People: Democrats Kill People"

Tony Prentakis


One of my liner lockers failed the 'knife on the table test'; but it was put together with allen screws, so I was able to dissamble it, and carefully, using a diamond file, reshape the locking surfaces. Now it passes all tests. HTH
cool.gif
 

Gandalf

Enlightened
Joined
Jul 3, 2001
Messages
802
Location
USA
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by phred:
Thank you Gandolf.
That is a very through articles.I printed them and will post them in my work shop.BTW, have you seen the Rekat line?...Awesome.
.....Dana....
smile.gif
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

Unfortunately, ever since I found this forum, all of my 'extra' $$$ have been going towards flashlights!!

I have yet to handle one of the new Benchmade or Sog Axis lock knives. I've become so fond of 2 of my knives, I rarely carry anything else: 1)Applegate/Fairbairn Covert in my front pants pocket, and a Kershaw Starkey (G10, Walker lock ATS-34) on my belt. These two knive seem to handle anything I want them to do, although most are minor cutting jobs indoors ( as opposed to the greater demads made on an 'outdoors' knife: like the fact than no folder would likely hold up!) I have anumber of very nice ones, including a Randall Fireman, and 2 Al Mars (can't remeber the names....) Lots of Sogs, of course. But all I seem to use for the better part of the past year are the first two folders. I guess I'm just more interested in flashlights these days....
cool.gif
wink.gif
 

sunspot

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
2,707
Location
Graham, NC
Thank you Gandolf.
That is a very through articles.I printed them and will post them in my work shop.BTW, have you seen the Rekat line?...Awesome.
.....Dana....
smile.gif
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
Gandalf,
Here is a website containing a review of the latest Al Mar manual folder.
http://www.jungletraining.com/almar.htm

It is quite sturdy and large enough to handle many outdoors tasks. I have one and it does ride VERY inconspicuously by virtue of the "lo-pro" clip.
I got interested in Al Mar products by none other than Al himself in the early eighties when he was still running his still fledging company. I met spoke with him only once and got "hooked" instantly. I have the older SERE model as well; purchased the day after speaking with AM.

<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Gandalf:
...like the fact than no folder would likely hold up!) I have anumber of very nice ones, including a Randall Fireman, and 2 Al Mars (can't remeber the names....)
cool.gif
wink.gif
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
 

sunspot

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
2,707
Location
Graham, NC
Thanks Kogatana and all else who reponded to my thread. I have ordered the Benchmade 942. $100. Guess what? REKAT or Al Mar? I know this is a light forum but I have gotten better advice here than Blade Forum. After all remember; GOD, Country, guns, lights, knives..
grin.gif
smile.gif
wink.gif
 

SPECIALIST

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
96
Location
USA
Go for www.emersonknives.com CQC7, I have a axis benchmade and like the CQC7 better. But if you want the benchmade, get it, i really like it. But, what are you using this knife for? If it is for heavy duty, go for the simple reliable emerson, you can disssameble it to clean it, the benchmade you cannot and with the axis lock, though not too complicated, has a higher chance of getting messed up. That is the reason why I get my 870 pump as apposed to my 1100 auto when I know Im going to be in a situation when I need reliablility NO COMPROMISE!
PS I have the gerber full size, i really dont like it, flimsy and no pocket clip. I keep it locked open next to my bed in a sheath next to my emerson for emergencies. The only thing it has going for it is that it is huge and real intimidating, to a scumball. But really to big for everyday carry.
!!!!It would be nice to have the next time a towel head wants to hyjack a plane with a butter knife!!!! Now this is a knife!!!!

#1 hard use knife in the world www.emersonknives.com
 

sunspot

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
2,707
Location
Graham, NC
Thanks Specialist. Funny you should mention Emerson CQC. I am looking close at that one. Also the Al Mar SERE 2000. The maker of Rekat seems to be losing it. QC is way off, and he is no longer responding on Bladeforum. Also see www.phonyveterans.com/ , they dislike him(to put it mildly). Anyway, back to the subject, I just want a knife(s) for carry only, not as a GP. As backup to my CCW. Sometimes you can't enter places(legaly) with a gun, so a knife will do. BTW, I also agree with KIS. I keep a Mossburg 590 pump in the house.
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
Someone please inform me what Rekat is (or whom). I remember reading about it a few years ago, but my memory does not serve me well right now.
 

SPECIALIST

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
96
Location
USA
I think its round eye knife and tool, what a shame, another scumbag trying to say he was an elite soldier. True silent professionals never brag, loud mouthed or show off their creds, thats one way to know they are for real. Many times you never even know the person is a vet unless someone else tells you, remeber WAR IS HELL and who wants to be reminded of his experiences in Hell.

PS I Just got a report in from one of my friends who is a LEO doing perimeter security for the WTC collapse, he said it looks like a small city bombed out, and he says he doesnt even want to look in the direction of the WTC because it is so depressing. He says the TV pics dont even come close to showing the disaster.
 
D

**DONOTDELETE**

Guest
Now I remember. I believe I bought a small, fixed blade from that company a few years ago. I either lost interest and gave it away, or it must have suffered the same fate as my TACMIII did; lost in a drawer somewhere in my house. I just looked at their website and did not find the model I purchased. They must have updated their product line, although I do remember that aggressive-looking Hobbit warrior model at the bottom of the page.
The Savant model caught my eye, however. The price is affordable. Any one have any experience with these products?
 

WillnTex

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Nov 27, 2000
Messages
95
Have you tried a Spyderco Matriarch. I just got one today finally it's just a bit shorter than the civilian but a real wicked looking knife. Ok it's not made to be a utility knife but ought to work out nicely for it's intended use.
 
Top