M64 - brightest 2D/NiMH/30min(ish) run? (inc vs. Mag85)

defblade

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 11, 2006
Messages
65
Inspiration and build:
Lots of parts came together for this magmod. I am trying to get as much light as possible out of a 2D mag (which slips into my coat's pocket nicely) while aiming for around half-an-hour's runtime, which is usually enough for me. Also want to stick with NiMH for now.

I got a FM tri-bored 2D mag (nice
smile.gif
) some time ago and the other parts have been coming in slowly.

I originally intended to replicate AWR's M85 (regulated Mag85) so I built a 9xGP2000 4/5A battery pack by end-to end soldering. Andrew warned there was little depth available for springs etc so I aimed to hardwire the pack to the mag switch.

Before getting the hotdriver, I constructed an un-regulated Mag85 for practise and made sure to rest the pack well before switching on. I did the major resistance fixes (tail spring, bulb holder spring and ground path) and used a FM bi-pin adaptor in the mag socket.

That was one nice, bright light, tho I did find the beam was artifacty on flood with a smooth reflector, and my medium stipple really killed the throw.

Then the excitement about the 1164 @ 9.6v started and so I decided to try them out.

The bulbs and hotdriver arrived at about the same time, so on with the build.


First the already modified switch needed a groove to allow the -ve hard wire to run through:

1grove.jpg



And then both wires were soldered onto the appropriate contacts. The +ve I've since moved down a couple of turns on the spring and made more groves in the underside of the switch to allow the wire to sit flush - that battery pack really is tight!

2switchsoldering.jpg



I started with mini Tamiya connectors, but while they fitted into the tailcap on their own, with wires attached, no way. So I tried bullet connectors from CBP. Here are the switch and a charging adaptor I made up:

3connectors.jpg


And the battery pack (the tape will be tided when I'm finished!):

4batteries.jpg




But these connectors were still so tight a fit that the tailcap was biting into the wire insulation
frown.gif


Some more looking around found some 9v snap connectors. They came with very thin wire, so I tried them at full length running the 1185 for 10 minutes, they didn't get more than slightly warm, so I cut them off as short as practical and they seem to work. Again, the tape will be tided and replaced with heat shrink when I'm done (going to run new wire everywhere too):

6connectors2.jpg





AWR was slightly worried that running the 9 cells into 9.6v would be more diference than the hotdriver would be happy with, but he then said (direct quote) "i'll replace the FET if it gets damaged in the name of science, so don't worry about trying." With a great offer like that, nothing to lose
evilgrin07.gif


And I was taken with the idea of being able to regulate the bulb through to what should be 1900mah or more of 2000mah quoted (they'll hold 1.1v to about 1900 at 15amps and I'm pulling just over 4amps). Which should give 25 minutes or so of running.

Amazingly, it all worked fine first time!






Review, comments and beamshots:
This torch is noticably brighter than the Mag85
smile.gif
So success there from the start
smile.gif


My Scout Troop are very impressed with the speed it sets paper on fire
evilgrin07.gif


The beam pattern, particularly with the smooth reflector, has what I instantly dubbed an "X-wing" artifact pattern (quick and dirty beamshot):
050M64XWing.jpg

: 4 "wing" shadows and a bright hotspot either side of the central shadow looking a bit like the engines (am I the only sad geek around?
rolleye11.gif
).




Anyway, this bulb throws much more light onto the trees down the field (150metres give or take) behind our house than the Mag85. Using the same smooth reflector each time, my ROP kinda reached them (you were aware of the hotspot without it really helping), the Mag 85 lit them a bit (enough to be useful), one tree at a time, the M64 lights them 3 at a time to the same sort of level as the Mag85. But the artifacts are really noticable. So it won't focus as tightly/cleanly but there's a lot more light down range.

The medium stipple (adjusted to the tightest spot it will) means that the Mag85 will hardly touch those trees (although the way to them is well lit!) but the M64 really starts to look good as the stipple cleans up the beam and doesn't seem to affect the throw much. So you end up with a bunch of nice light over 2 or 3 trees.

Turning the MS to flood, the M64 really fills my whole back garden - looks like day time to my eyes. Reaches a good half way across the field too. The Mag85 was already OK like this but the MS sacrificed too much throw to want to use it.






I've got a simple-ish digital camera, which does have manual control so I know the settings are similar for all these photos. However, they are very underexposed compared to what my eyes see and it's been too cold to want to mess around with the settings too much, so the pics below aren't as much use as they could be (all suggestions greatfully received). They were taken at iso100 f2-6 speed1-15. The trees used are in our back garden, not the ones down the field. I also tried the camera on these, and its automatic mode, across the field but it couldn't pick anything up.

The spot pictures are clipped but otherwise untampered with, the M64 is slightly brighter overall but not a great difference at this range. Despite the pictures looking black otherwise, the spill beam on each is doing a reasonable job of lighting everything else (much better than the spot of a standard 2D mag!).

The flood pictures I had to work on the contrast with. I used the automatic settings on PaintShopPro, I'm not sure if the same settings have different actions on different pictures. When I put them all together, I was suprised to see that the sky was coming brighter as well on the M64 pics, especially the med stipple shot. I looked for a while, and wondered about the image program as above, but decided that despite the washed out colours (bright and clear to my eyes in real life) and possible enhancment problems, the pictures were actually a pretty good represenation of the differences between the torches. So maybe it's the limitations of the camera. Anyhow, the M64 on med stipple flood really is that much better than the Mag85. Lights the trees, the hedge, the climbing frame, everything
smile.gif
Also notice artifacts on the M64 smooth shot
frown.gif


spotssmall.jpg


floodssmall.jpg






Summary:

I love throw so I'm waiting to get FM's 3" head on this, but until then I'd say, with the medium stipple reflector, it's got the Mag85 either drawn or beaten on every count. The smooth gives too poor a beam quality to want to use.

Anyone got a light stipple I could try
wink.gif
?

Or any ideas on getting any more light out a 2D?
 
Last edited:

andrewwynn

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 28, 2004
Messages
3,763
Location
Racine, WI USA
the beamshot looks a bit like you might not be able to get the lamp into focus.. some of the lamps we have to make the ceramic socket shorter removing the stand offs and using nuts for spacers. unless you are sure you are getting past the focus.. you should try that modification Those screws are M3 metric. it is not difficult to retrofit the driver to shorten the length just don't harass the wires too bad as they are being bent into a bow to fit down lower.

nice to see this lamp finally come to fruition i've been talking with folks about this exact lamp since about august or september.

-awr
 

Northern Lights

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 17, 2006
Messages
1,267
Location
Southwest
WOW, Defblade, congratulations! That is great to see, I could only imagine before but I new that would be a great combination.
I have the exact same parts for a 2D M64 sitting on my desk and am hard wiring the GP2000 too to the switch. Hotdriver etc. but my problem is the hang up with my machinist and I do not have my bored tube back. AWR was a great help with the conception and tech specs! I usually frost my bulbs, the lower 2/3 and use smooth reflectors, that could help your beam pattern too. Maybe next week I will get my tri-bore tube back! I have been flip flopping on whether to keep it, do I really need another light? Or sell it in the forum, but your post is got me considering to keep it. I originally was building it for the same reason you said, convenience and practical Lumens!
 
Last edited:

defblade

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 11, 2006
Messages
65
andrewwynn said:
some of the lamps we have to make the ceramic socket shorter removing the stand offs and using nuts for spacers.

Was wondering if this was the case..... I've got a standard KIU kicking around now so I will pull them both out sometime and compare heights.... might be why I've been having trouble with one of the other (less standard/more interesting) reflectors blowing bulbs, too.
 

Icebreak

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 14, 2002
Messages
4,998
Location
by the river
defblade -

Thanks for posting this.

Looking at the white wall shot on flood it appears that your lamp is laterally focused quite well. At first I thought your torch might be having some axial focus problems and I'm still not sure. However, in the color shots I can't tell if the Mag85 SMO spot is axially focused but the M64 SMO spot does appear to be axially focused correctly.

If these two set ups were compared like you did in the black and white shots more would be revealed.

Either way the WA01164 appears to be much more powerful than the WA01185.

Now I'm wondering if, in a standard 3D Mag85 set up, that the new IB 2000 AA NiMhs could be used with a WA01164 and get similar performance to that of your torch. Larger package for sure but the expense for the upgrade might be worth it. That much light for 30 minutes is fine for many purposes.

On an aside...
defblade said:
might be why I've been having trouble with one of the other (less standard/more interesting) reflectors blowing bulbs, too.
If that's the 2" deep FiveMega be careful that the lamp, at all focus points, doesn't touch the reflector. Long shot guess but I thought I'd mention it.

Anyway, your M64 is one of the more interesting incans I've seen in a while. Thanks again for posting about it. Exciting stuff.

- Jeff
 

defblade

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 11, 2006
Messages
65
Icebreak said:
If that's the 2" deep FiveMega be careful that the lamp, at all focus points, doesn't touch the reflector. Long shot guess but I thought I'd mention it.

Not such a long shot ;) I've lost 3 bulbs already but I didn't mention this as I'm sure it's something to do with my set up and not FM's great work.

Only happens as or just after I move the bezel down from spot to flood and I'm fairly sure it's hitting something down there. The stack height of the hotdriver + KIU is quite tall so that's the first thing I'll be working on, and maybe some packing to make sure the reflector centres on the KIU. I'm not sure it if's possible that the sheer heat of the lamp is being concentrated enough as the lamp moves up into the reflector to blow it? Only seems to happen while the torch is pointing down.... Anyhow, I've put it to one side for now (it does clean all the smooth artifacts up nicely; gives a bright, round spot) and waiting for the 3"ers to come :)


I've got a stack of those new 2000 AAs coming for a 3D mag85; and enough CBP1650s for two 8 cell packs to run a single unbored, unregulated mag64, so I can carry a back up pack. I'm waiting to see if the 2000s will fit 4 wide in an unbored mag.......
 
Last edited:

Icebreak

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 14, 2002
Messages
4,998
Location
by the river
Cool. I'll be watching.

Thanks again for the time, expense and effort needed for your experiments and reporting.
 

Hallis

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 23, 2004
Messages
2,590
Location
Dallas, Tx
Nice writeup there. I'm tempted to build another incan now :) This time with the 1164 and maybe a hotdriver. Do you think Mini deans connectors would work? I've thought about upgrading my Mag85 with the IB2000's. It's currently running CBP1650's which i love. The cells only have about half a cycle through them so far, lol. Took the light outside for the first time last night. Usually I just blast it at the wall for my own enjoyment haha. The Hotdriver is definately a good idea for the soft startup. Do you think that the wire issue might be resolvable by using a straight 9(4/5 aa)/ 2d battery back with the standard pads on either end and then just modifying the tailspring almost all the way down or build yourself some kind of custom pirch for the tailcap? I use 12aa/3d stick packs in my polaris and they work great. Just charge them with magnet leads and all is right with the world. I'll have to stop by the home depot today and see if they have any pewter or silver 2d's on hand.

Shane
 

defblade

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 11, 2006
Messages
65
Don't see why cutting the spring down wouldn't work (That's what AWR did on his M85 IIRC). I can't find actual size of the mini Dean's - I did look at them - again, looks like just the connectors would fit in the tailcap space OK, but the wires coming out maybe troublesome. A good thing with wiring a pack in is that you remove the resistance loses in the springs (tho the clip connector wires I'm using maybe putting a similar amount back in?!).

If you're using 8 cells with the 1164 and no regulator, there may be space for narrow connectors (eg staggered bullets) in the 9th cell's slot? Or more space below the battery pack if you're using thinner AAs in a 4+4 pattern pack?
 

Hallis

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 23, 2004
Messages
2,590
Location
Dallas, Tx
I know a mag can be bored to accept 4aa stacks. Making the pack might be difficult with 9 cells but who knows. I think i might try this but i'll need somebody else to pre-build my pack as i dont have the end-to-end soldering skills. And then i'll have to find somebody to bore the mag. I'll have to see if Mac, Modamag, or somebody else can get that done for me.

Shane
 

andrewwynn

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 28, 2004
Messages
3,763
Location
Racine, WI USA
i recommend just making a drop-in pack and use contacts vs hard-wire with connectors.. it was not all that difficult to make the pack... you can actually get a pack pre-welded from cbp in the tri config and just make some plates for each end.. use the likes of pcb or plastic for the base and glue on a copper disc on each side for pos and neg, soldering to the end tab of each.. some shrink wrap to hold it all together and you have a drop-in pack..

you can look here to see how i made the prototype packs for the M85 and M625.. I expect in about a month i can release the smartpak which has the boards already made.. if i wasn't so busy trying to get unburied i could offer to sell just the boards if people were interested in making their own rods and possibly forgoing the fancy stuff like the charge jack and fuse.

oh.. if you need 4mm extra space inside a maglight.. cut off the ribbing on the bottom of the switch!

-awr
 
Last edited:

defblade

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 11, 2006
Messages
65
defblade said:
I'm waiting to see if the IB 2000s will fit 4 wide in an unbored D mag.......

No, they don't :( Not for me anyway, including making sure the sleeve joins are all towards the middle.
 

defblade

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 11, 2006
Messages
65
Set to 9.6v. I dare say it could be squeezed higher but I'll wait for the next group buy on 1164s before I start really pushing them as I've only got 2 left!
 

LuxLuthor

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 5, 2005
Messages
10,653
Location
MS
Your post got me interested in this one light I got a while back using the 1164 & 8xAA's. When I measure the voltage with the light turned on, and freshly charged Sanyo's it is 9.7-9.9V, but it is not even close to my Mag66 in brightness. Using the re-rating formulas at WA's website, the 1164 in this setup should be giving 1500 BL, and the 1166 about 970 BL....but the '66 is clearly brighter.

I really have no idea why the 1164 is not way brighter.
 

LuxLuthor

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 5, 2005
Messages
10,653
Location
MS
fivemega said:
LuxLuthor,
Did you measure voltage at battery pack or bulb pins?
Battery pack plug in jack wires. I see the big difference now with clipping a small aligator clamp on the bipin wires. Thanks for that.
 

LED BriCK

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 29, 2005
Messages
272
Location
Baltimore
I have a Mag85 with AWR's HD run off of 9 CBP1650's. If I rerate the 1164 to this V, I get 2359 bulb lumens at 4.53A of current and a bulb life of 2.16 hours (please feel free to check my math if this seems off, I'm a rerating n00b). I'm not too concerned about the bulb life (live fast, die young, right?), but does anyone think there's something else I might burn out or otherwise destroy with this setup?
 
Top