I don't know if there are Galyans in Ohio, but they carry several of the lights listed for decent retail prices. I just bought three original Impacts for $12 each as the packaging was damaged a bit. Very impressive light. At first, it doesn't seem much brighter than the Brinkmann 2 AA lights, and maybe inside there isn't a world of difference. But outdoors, it has much more usable light. For shining things up to 50 feet or so. We're not talking SureFire G2/Legend LX/Princeton Surge bright, but bright enough to see if someone or a small animal is there. Plus, LEDs tend to show color differences if not actual colors so if someone is standing there against a predominantly green background, wearing black or gray, you'll see them. And if there's something small and furry, you can easily pick out the eyes.
The Impact would be my strong recommendation if you don't need to to be super small.