From what i can tell,, my Brinkman REBEL's rubber cannot be removed, if you did, it would leave a huge mess.
Water proofness???? I am thinking the Brinkmann would be better. Heres why,,,, theres only ONE place for the water to get in. The Mag has TWO. And the tail on the Brinkmann is a very very tight fit.
I am not familiar with the Brinkmann 2aa light. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/frown.gif