Olight - S1R        
Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and more!

  1. #1

    Rolleye11 NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and more!

    Reviewer's Note: The Dear 123 was provided for review by NaitHawk. Please see their CPFMP Manufacturer’s thread for more info.

    Warning: pic heavy, as usual.

    Manufacturer's specifications, condensed from their CPFMP thread:
    • LED: Cree XR-E R2 (WC) LED
    • Max Output: 200 lumens
    • Mode: Low- - High - Beacon Strobe
    • Output&Runtime:
    • 3V Lithium batteries: Maximum output is 180 Lumens about (118 minutes), Minimum output is 16 Lumens about (28 hours), Beacon Strobe 1 Hz (8 hours)
    • 3.6V Lithium batteries: Maximum output is 200 Lumens for about (75minutes), Minimum output is 22 Lumens for about (16 hours), Beacon Strobe 1 Hz (3.5 hours)
    • Switch: Tighten off - unscrew to open
    • Battery: CR123A or 16340 Lithium batteries
    • Circuit : Constant current circuit
    • Material: Damascus pattern-welded steel
    • Waterproof: to IPX-8 standard
    • Surface Treatment: polished or drawn wire treatment
    • Lens: Double-sided coating, the light transmission rate of 97%
    • Reflector: High-quality aluminum half orange peel reflector
    • Dimension: 74 mm(length) × 19.5mm (diameter)
    • Weight: 75g (without battery)
    • Accessories: O-Rings,Operator’s Manual, Multi-function Waterproof Box
    • MSRP $239

    The Dear 123 is unusual looking light from a new manufacturer known as NaitHawk. The distinctiveness of the light comes from the construction material used – so-called pattern Damascus steel.



    First a bit of background – NaitHawk describes this light as a "pattern Damascus steel flashlight." Damascus steel refers to a form of folded-over, hot-forged steel that was used in Middle Eastern sword-making during the Middle Ages. Famed for its strength and sharpness, the original recipes and methods of Damascus steel production are believed to have been lost several centuries ago.

    FYI, here is a close-up of an actual 13th century Damascus steel sword that I photographed in a Middle Eastern museum in Qatar:



    Of interest today, a product with a somewhat similar appearance can be produced through a method called “pattern welding.” Widely used in custom knife making, pattern welding involves welding together two or more types of steels with different nickel and/or carbon content, in order to capture their respective properties and advantages in the final product.

    This method can produce alternating dark and light stripes, similar to what you see in Damascus steel. As such, you will sometimes see pattern-welded steel called Damascus steel today – although to be more accurate, this should probably be referred to as "Damascened” steel, since there is debate and controversy surrounding the original Damascus steel production methods (e.g. see the Wikipedia entry for an example of how confused discussions on this material can be).

    Suffice it to say, the modern pattern welded steel it should be pretty strong – and definitely pretty to look at.



    The light comes in a good quality re-sealable plastic carrying container, with foam inserts to securely hold the light. Under the bottom foam piece you will find the extra o-rings and instruction manual.







    From left to right: Surefire CR123A, 4Sevens MiNi 123, ITP A1, NaitHawk Dear 123, Nitecore EX10, 4Sevens Quark 123, Novatac 120P, 4Sevens MiNi Titanium

    Dear 123: Weight 69.7g, Length 72.9mm x Width 19.5mm (bezel)

    Dimensions are reasonable for this sort of twisty light. Weight is higher than typical, due to the steel construction.

    Fit and finish are very unique - the pattern welded steel has interesting llight/dark stripes running throughout the material. Although you can feel the difference by touch, the effect is subtle (except for perhaps the ends of the light where it is more noticeable). Note that this is indeed true pattern welding and not just a surface modification – if you look at the screw thread shot below, you can see the pattern continues throughout.





    The head appears to be sitting within a brass heatsink, which directly screws into the body/battery tube. Some of the brass heatsink is visible in the gap between the head and body.

    Internally, the light has what appears to be a brass base with a short post at the negative battery terminal. However, this is just a contact cover - underneath that center post is a spring, which will help prevent this light from crushing your cells.



    The light can tailstand, although there is unfortunately no attachment point for a lanyard anywhere.



    Surprising for a new light, the emitter used is the standard Cree XR-E (R2 output bin, WC tint bin). Reflector is reasonably deep, and heavily textured.




    And now for the requisite white wall hunting … all lights are on Max with on AW RCR, about 0.5 meters from a white wall.




    Beam pattern is fairly good for a Cree XR-E, with only a minimal dark rink around the hospot (i.e. similar to Cree XR-E Q5 EX10 above). Not sure why NaitHawk isn’t using the more common XP-E/XP-G emitter, but XR-E does typically produce greater throw.

    Tint is very good on my sample, so the WC tint bin spec is believable. For those of you not familiar with tint bins, please see my Colour tint comparison and the summary LED tint charts found here.

    User Interface

    The Dear 123 has three output modes: Lo, Hi and Beacon.

    Like a number of twisty lights, the Dear 123 is off when the head is fully tightened against the body. To activate the light, simply loosen the head slightly. The initial output mode is Lo, and the light has mode memory (i.e. leave it off for awhile, it will come back on at the last mode used).

    To advance to the next output mode, do a tighten-loosen twist from on (i.e. on-off-on) within a sec or so. The next mode will be Hi. Do a tighten-loosen twist again and you will get the Beacon mode. Modes repeat in the Lo – Hi – Beacon sequence.

    The Beacon mode is quite interesting – it is basically a 1 flash per second strobe (actually, more like 0.9 Hz):



    Although NaitHawk claims current-controlled output, I was able to detect a re-occuring signal at 4.2kHz when on Lo. This would seem to suggest PWM is used for Lo, but the frequency is high enough that you can't detect it by eye.

    Testing Method: All my output numbers are relative for my home-made light box setup, a la Quickbeam's flashlightreviews.com method. You can directly compare all my relative output values from different reviews - i.e. an output value of "10" in one graph is the same as "10" in another. All runtimes are done under a cooling fan, except for the extended run Lo/Min modes (i.e. >12 hours) which are done without cooling.

    Throw values are the square-root of lux measurements taken at 1 meter from the lens, using a light meter.

    Throw/Output Summary Chart:





    Max Output and throw are roughly what I would have expected for a XR-E-based light. It is not a barn burner, but it is reasonable for a light this size.

    Lo mode is similar to other 2-stage lights.

    Output/Runtime Comparison:

    Note: Effective January 2010, all CR123A runtimes are now performed solely on Titanium Innovations batteries sponsored by BatteryJunction.com. You can compare the generally excellent performance of these CR123A cells relative to the Duracell/Surefire cells used in all my earlier reviews here. I have marked all the new runtimes of lights with Titanium Innovations CR123As on the graphs with an "*".






    Performance on Hi is pretty much as I would have expected. Efficiency seems rather good on the Lo output mode (especially on RCR), relative to the competition.

    Potential Issues

    Battery tube internal diameter is narrow – most of my protected AW RCR wouldn’t fit pass the screw threads. Since the light has no tailcap, if you a force a battery in, you may not be able to get it out.

    Steel is not as good a conductor of heat as aluminum, but the brass heatsink should help in this case.

    UPDATE 4/13/2010: I originally thought the light used a solid post for the negative terminal, but I see now that is is indeed spring-mounted. This should remove the potential risk of crushing a battery.

    There is no wrist/lanyard strap attachment point.

    Preliminary Observations

    The Dear 123 is certainly one of the more distinctive lights I’ve reviewed in the 1xCR123A class.

    Although I am not generally a fan of stainless steel construction, the pattern welding technique used here produces a very unique looking product (and one that should be quite durable). The very solid build - including brass internal components and heatsink – inspires further confidence that this light is built to last.

    User interface is reasonable for a general-purpose twisty light (i.e. Lo, Hi, Beacon), and the efficiency is very good for a two-stage light. Personally, I rather like the beacon mode with its slow 0.9 Hz signal (i.e. just under once per second). Very useful for signaling purposes (I can’t see myself ever using a tactical strobe – I’m more likely to disorient myself if I were to try ).

    The emitter choice is interesting – most makers have switched to the smaller profile XP-E/XP-Gs (which are also capable of higher outputs). Not sure why NaitHawk has chosen to stick with the original XR-E. But they have gone for the highest XR-E output bin (R2), premium cool white tint (WC), and a heavily textured reflector to reduce rings.

    All in all, the Dear 123 is a sturdy and attractive light from a new manufacturer. Although clearly marketed for those looking for a bit of "bling" (and willing to pay for it), the user interface is consistent with a number of popular general purpose lights.
    Last edited by selfbuilt; 04-13-2010 at 09:27 AM.
    Full list of all my reviews: flashlightreviews.ca. Latest hobby: whiskyanalysis.com. Latest flashlight review: Thrunite TN42.
    Gratefully accepting donations to my battery fund.

  2. #2
    Flashaholic* gswitter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    California
    Posts
    2,586

    Default Re: NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and m

    Great review, as usual. The light has some interesting aspects, but, overall, it's not for me.

    I'll reserve it a spot in the the Product (and Company) Name Hall of Shame.



  3. #3
    Light11's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    The Great Northwest
    Posts
    1,591

    Default Re: NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and m

    Excellent review selfbuilt
    do you know if Naithawk has any plans of upgrading to an XP-G and what type of finish is there on your Sample, Smooth or drawn wire?

  4. #4

    Default Re: NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and m

    Quote Originally Posted by gswitter View Post
    I'll reserve it a spot in the the Product (and Company) Name Hall of Shame.
    I'll admit, it doesn't naturally roll off the tongue. But on the plus side, at least the model name isn't some over-the-top superlative. I'd certainly rather refer to a light as "dear" than explain that "sacred fire" I'm carrying in pocket.

    Quote Originally Posted by Light11 View Post
    do you know if Naithawk has any plans of upgrading to an XP-G and what type of finish is there on your Sample, Smooth or drawn wire?
    I've asked NaitHawk about the XP-E/XP-G, we'll see what they say. As for the finish, I would describe it as smooth with slight ridge detail. I'm not sure what drawn wire would feel like, but I imagine that must be a lot more textured.
    Full list of all my reviews: flashlightreviews.ca. Latest hobby: whiskyanalysis.com. Latest flashlight review: Thrunite TN42.
    Gratefully accepting donations to my battery fund.

  5. #5

    Default Re: NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and m

    Thanks very much for your informative review!

    The only thing I would like to throw in is a comment about this light being a "potential battery crusher". My lights' negative battery post is indeed spring loaded and has no potential for crushing the battery. I will admit the cells do fit tight but I only use AW cells and all of mine fit and they work fine.

    The first Dear123 I received lasted for less than an hour before for no apparent reason. I will say that I received amazing support from Naithawk (despite their name choice!). Susie from Naithawk had a new unit to me within days that I have been 100% satisfied with. (I still have to return the defective unit, thanks Susie!)

    In my experience with both of the units I have handled, AW protected cells have fit tight but fine. I do have the wire drawn textured one.. Maybe thats a difference? Both units also have the spring loaded brass negative terminal.

    Thanks again for another great review!

  6. #6

    Default Re: NaitHawk Dear 123 Review (Pattern Welded CR123A): RUNTIMES, BEAMSHOTS, PICS and m

    Quote Originally Posted by Captain Spaulding View Post
    The only thing I would like to throw in is a comment about this light being a "potential battery crusher". My lights' negative battery post is indeed spring loaded and has no potential for crushing the battery. I will admit the cells do fit tight but I only use AW cells and all of mine fit and they work fine.
    Thanks for the catch - the negative post is indeed spring loaded. I have just updated the review.

    As for the AW cells, I am glad yours work fine - hopefully it is just my sample that is narrow around the threads. Here's a detailed breakdown on mine:

    Modern AW protected cells: 6 tried, only 1 would fit (1 more may have fit with some force, but I was unwilling to try)
    Early black-label AW protected cells (white top): 2 tried, neither fit
    Older blue-label AW protected cells: 2 tried, 1 fit.
    Gray Ultrafire protected cells: 1 tried, no fit.

    Full list of all my reviews: flashlightreviews.ca. Latest hobby: whiskyanalysis.com. Latest flashlight review: Thrunite TN42.
    Gratefully accepting donations to my battery fund.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •