archer6817j
Enlightened
Hi all, so I have a little quandary. I'm trying to figure out why an XML gets WAY hotter than an MCE in the same application where everything is identical except for the emitter (and star thickness). I can run the MCE on high for an unlimited amount of time if I hold it in my hand. It gets hot...but not "really" hot.
XML mounted to a 1.6mm x 20mm star runs about 20 degrees (F) hotter than the MCE at the same 2.8A drive current (measured at the tail).
Several people have suggested the linear driver is giving off more heat because the XML vf is lower than the MCE. Plausible. However, after running the light for 10 minutes and the head is very hot, I can remove the head and put my finger on the driver...and it's barely warm. I will try and measure actual vf's tomorrow, but even if the XML vf is lower, it doesn't seem to be related to the driver and excess voltage.
As a side note, the MCE drops about 25 lumens between turn on and 30 seconds and begins to stabilize. The XML drops nearly 60 lumens and I assume this is due to the rapid heat build up.
Does anyone else have identical MCE and XML lights to compare? Any thoughts on what is causing this? I'm wondering if it's "me" or something inherent in the XML (or the MCE). I've observed an identical effect with multiple lights so it's not just a single "quirky" setup.
I haven't been industrious enough to bench test the two LED's side by side with a power supply, mainly because I don't have an accurate way to measure temperature differences. Thoughts? Advice? Thanks!
- MCE mounted to a 2mm x 20mm star.
- Battery is 1x18650
- Driver is a shiningbeam 2.8A 3 mode (linear)
XML mounted to a 1.6mm x 20mm star runs about 20 degrees (F) hotter than the MCE at the same 2.8A drive current (measured at the tail).
Several people have suggested the linear driver is giving off more heat because the XML vf is lower than the MCE. Plausible. However, after running the light for 10 minutes and the head is very hot, I can remove the head and put my finger on the driver...and it's barely warm. I will try and measure actual vf's tomorrow, but even if the XML vf is lower, it doesn't seem to be related to the driver and excess voltage.
As a side note, the MCE drops about 25 lumens between turn on and 30 seconds and begins to stabilize. The XML drops nearly 60 lumens and I assume this is due to the rapid heat build up.
Does anyone else have identical MCE and XML lights to compare? Any thoughts on what is causing this? I'm wondering if it's "me" or something inherent in the XML (or the MCE). I've observed an identical effect with multiple lights so it's not just a single "quirky" setup.
I haven't been industrious enough to bench test the two LED's side by side with a power supply, mainly because I don't have an accurate way to measure temperature differences. Thoughts? Advice? Thanks!