ExtremeBeam Alpha-TAC XT8 with the Metal MOLLE right-angle adaptor - Review

[RedForest UK]

Thanks to Norm for providing a new link to the second thread with the dead link, it appears that it wasn't completely removed, so the situation has become less mysterious (implying something dodgy going on ) and more just confusing. Here it is anyway:

http://www.candlepowerforums.com/vb/...ead.php?337145

[127.0.0.1]

peeps....

if you think the extremebeam deal is not settled, for whatever reason.....I still wanna see someone do a real
review so we can see... not the thicker bodies, but the electronics and materials inside, is it junk, same as ultrafire, or what ?


If no one steps up and tries for a more exhaustive side-by-side of extremebeam vs it's apparent clone, then subwoofer
(this review) will end up getting my $100 bucks after 2012 ends....as the only reviewer who did anything (even though it
doesn't meet the '100 dollar review' deal)

so, I am losing $100 bucks not matter what, but I'd rather not give it to this review. I will though, if no one else steps up.

[127.0.0.1]

I don't understand why you are so open to giving away $100. If a review doesn't meet the criteria set then why give it the $100. I was under the impression that the $100 was for compensation for purchasing the light from extrembeam itself but some may not be comfortable giving them that much money anyway. I would do it but I can see just as many possible complaints about me doing a review from my own viewpoint as it is clearly not entirely impartial.

I would try contacting some well known reviewers who have a lot of reference lights to compare to, or people who often disassemble lights and report back. I would recommend contacting selfbuilt, HKJ, and people like ergotelis and vinhnguyen possibly. You could well find some very good reviewers over at BLF too who are technically minded and have good experience with budget lights qualities and deficiencies, after all most reviews over there already include comparisons to the cheaper ***fire lights anyway.

1) I never really said the 100 bucks is for any specific purpose, I said it is 100 bucks. do whatever you want with it
2) side by side review, I said
3) subwoofer asked, I said no...but to make sure I do not look like a chump [and there really is no
100 dollars], I am gonna man-up and send 100 bucks to 'someone', to prove I am not just a windbag

so if someone does it better and a review that generates less controversy (in other words public opinion
should be 'yeah it was a neutral un-biased review') that person gets the 100 bucks

if no one steps up, the 100 bucks has to go to someone or I am a lying b**ch, right ?

I am not funding anything, I just want someone with the skills and review skills to maybe
have some incentive to 'work on the extremebeam controversy' in a little more detail than
a standard review, since extremebeam pumps 'a little bit more hype' into marketing

[RedForest UK]

Ok, fair enough.

I would strongly recommend signing up to BLF and advertising it there as well though, you may well get a few takers and some good choice of who you feel is best qualified to do a 'teardown' of the light based on their previous reviews. You can then cross-post the review over here with confirmation that the $100 challenge has been accepted and paid out along with hopefully a very good insight into the build quality and performance differences between the extremebeam and the 'knock-offs'.

I also would have no issue with subwoofer doing the review himself, I just feel he would need to do a little more of a technical exploration of the internals of a light to justify earning the $100. Or even just doing it on the drop-in of the light covered in this review would be better than nothing, with pictures if possible and in comparison to the build quality of the 'generic R2' drop-in.

[127.0.0.1]

Ok, fair enough.

I would strongly recommend signing up to BLF and advertising it there as well though, you may well get a few takers and some good choice of who you feel is best qualified to do a 'teardown' of the light based on their previous reviews. You can then cross-post the review over here with confirmation that the $100 challenge has been accepted and paid out along with hopefully a very good insight into the build quality and performance differences between the extremebeam and the 'knock-offs'.

this is for current CPF members and reviewers only, I will post nothing on any other forum about it

[127.0.0.1]

upon further review, careful consideration and thought, this doesn't qualify, no 100 bucks
for this review.