Alan: I have the standard reflector.
Lightmight:
The Edison appears slightly whiter than the Storm. The beam appears very slightly bluer at the lower brightness setting.
Throw: I have a sense from using both that the Edison has a better throw, it's not a spot but it has significant reach. I can check it out this weekend on patrol in New Hampshire.
Here's my problem with NiteRider: Sometimes the battery seems to give up far earlier than I would have expected. I was on a search a few weeks ago in the middle of the night in the dense fog. My storm, after less than 2 hours of light, went dead, and it was fully charged. My range went from 30 feet to 3 feet as soon as I switched on my Tikka. I felt almost as lost as our lost hiker except I had a radio and a pack full of gear to spend the night if I had to. That's when I called Gretna's in Pennsylvania and had them ship me the Edison 5. The battery seems to hold up better and longer, and there don't seem to be the same connection problems that NR has, and also it is far far lighter in weight than the Storm- both the headpiece and the battery, which you start to notice after about 24 hours on the trail. Both NR and Lupine have solid looking units, but the Lupine feels more positive, just hard to describe I guess. It's definitely brighter, although for most purposes in SAR you don't need quite that much light, and the other rangers and fish and game officers kind of resent you for a. having a better light and b. blinding them if you accidentally point it in their direction. I've taken recently to hiking down with another ranger after dark with the light facing the other direction, using the peripheral glow of the light to light the trail, and only using the HID lights when I'm alone. But hikers appreciate the security/reassurance of someone coming upon them with a truly powerful blast of light when they're benighted or struggling to find their way down in the dark. It also helps speed people up who are kind of scaird of hiking in the dark, especially when they're tired and feeling weak. That for me is the main reason for using NR or Lupine- although I've also used it draw out lost hikers who see the beam sometimes before they hear my whistle.
Hope that helps. Check with me next week after I've had a chance to compare NR and Lupine to answer your questions better.