Review: Manker U21 18650-26650 (Beamshots, Runtime, Pics)

Budda

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 30, 2009
Messages
590
Location
Italy
Manker was kind enough to supply me a U21 for the review.

Manker's specs:
- Emitter Type: CREE XHP35 HI
- Max Lumens Output: 1300lumens
- Maximum Beam Intensity: 124000cd
- Maximum Beam Distance: 700 meters
- Working Voltage: 2.8-4.35v
- USB Charging Current: 2A (Over charge and discharge protection)
- Circuit Driver: PFM/PWM Synchronous booster intelligent conversion circuit Intelligence Lithium battery charge design
- Reflector: aluminum reflector
- Material: Aero grade aluminum alloy (Surface treatment: Premium type III hard anodized anti-abrasive finish,Thickness> 50μm
- Switch Type: Electronic Click switch
- Length: 148mm, Head diameter: 59mm, Body diameter: 35mm
- Weight: 290g (without battery)
- Shockproof standard: 1.5m
- Waterproof Standard: IPX-7
_zpscqi6lcyc.jpg


The U21 comes in a big cardboard box.
Inside the box: light, spare o-rings, battery adapter, lanyard, micro USB cable and manual (English and Chinese).
DSCN0563_zpssbpnpek2.jpg

DSCN0566_zpskkmzmrfk.jpg

DSCN0567_zpswspayb72.jpg



The U21 has an electronic switch at the head
DSCN0569_zpsrhd38ii5.jpg


There is some knurling on the light, and the anodization is matte black.
DSCN0575_zpspke4npgl.jpg


In the big and smooth reflector there is a CREE XHP35 Hi emitter, CW 6000K.
DSCN0574_zpscwiw9ceu.jpg


The switch on one side, on the other the micro USB port for charging the light. The rubber cover when it is in position stays recessed.
DSCN0570_zpsqqlaoxbu.jpg

DSCN0571_zpsybipxmmo.jpg

DSCN0573_zpssnpn51zg.jpg


Under the electronic switch there is a red-orange led, like the blue one on the U11. The rubber cover of the switch can be removed by untwisting the metal bezel.
DSCN0674_zpshq7nsa9i.jpg

Here with the Manker U11 dragon breath mode
output_8MQVwh_zpsgazn5ske.gif


Well machined and anodized threads (you can physically lockout the light by unscrewing the tailcap or the head).
DSCN0584_zpskfyirhxa.jpg


At the tailcap and at the head, the contact points are double nested golden springs. This is a solution that decreases the resistance and allows more current to pass. No physical protection against polarity inversion.
DSCN0582_zpspdpqbdbl.jpg

DSCN0585_zpsj0vaqyuj.jpg

DSCN0589_zpsuznscyhb.jpg


The translucent plastic battery spacer allows the use of an 18650 battery inside the battery tube that can fit a 26650 battery.
DSCN0586_zpshdljtdn8.jpg


U21, U21… what is inside your head?
DSCN0578_zpsw0pa68n7.jpg

An AR treated glass, a big and heavy threated aluminium reflector (it screws inside the head of the light) and a big baseplate for the LED.
DSCN0580_zpsxdc98old.jpg


Some pics with other lights
DSCN0815_zpsbyddjjg7.jpg

DSCN0814_zpsoymqmscc.jpg

DSCN0807_zpsnqi8ukbe.jpg




UI
The U21 has a UI similar to the one of the U11, but simpler.
From off, one short click turns the light on at the lowest level.
From off, a long click turns the light on at the last used level (low mode does not count).
When the light is on, a double click gives you strobe mode.
A single click when the light is on advances in the next mode (low medium hi turbo if you are in the constant output mode, strobe SOS and dragon flash if you are in the flashing mode).
There is a shortcut for dragon flash: from off make 3 double click.
When the light is on dragon flash, a single click will activate the SOS, a double click will activate the last used mode.
In dragon flash mode, the led under the switch will slowly turn on and off, dimming.
When the battery is running low, the led under the switch will stay on.


Output, Beamshots, Runtime.
For powering the U21 and getting max performances, Manker recommends to use IMR cells, and advices to not use protected cells. This because the PCB of protected cells may trip and stop the battery.
I do not have any 26650s, so I tested the output using two different 18650 batteries: LG MJ1 and LG HG2, unprotected batteries. I got no differences, so for the runtime test I used the LG MJ1, since they provide the same output as the HG2 but better runtime.

The outputs measured are higher on all levels, compared to Manker specs. I do not show the low mode value because of my improvised setup: it has too much error at low measurements.
Output%20U21_zpsnsx7gpzz.png


I measured:
- Low 369 Cd
- Mid1 13'650 Cd
- Mid2 37'250 Cd
- Hi 69'400 Cd
- Turbo 119'600 Cd

Beamshots, at 1 meter from the wall.
DSCN0601_zps5obhvky9.jpg

DSCN0598_zpsfpxzfan6.jpg

DSCN0597_zpsop5p0m9j.jpg


Real world Beamshots. To my eyes the pics I took with the 4" exposure are less bright than the light, and the one with the 8" exposure are overexposed. Here are the pics with 4".
A bit more than 100 meters (120?)
U21%204sec%20S%201_zpsebb1xg2q.jpg

U21%202sec%20S%201_zpsvt9jhnfz.jpg


280 meters at the building
U21%204sec%20S%202_zpsae3ou0z7.jpg

U21%202sec%20S%202_zps1vmhwolv.jpg

U21%20zoom%204sec%20S%20%202_zpscw8vgyps.jpg


The sampling rate on the luxmeter is 2" for the turbo measurement, 60" for all the other levels tested.
A member on another forum asked if I could bypass the stepdown by turning the light off and on again.
I did some test and graphs. But I got very different results from my previous runtime graph: the stepdown is very very low.
The Turbo curve I get now is completely different from the one I published before. I checked the data log from that old test, and I can't find any error.
However, I tested the first 10 minutes of runtime at turbo 3 times with 2 different cells and got the same results... This can't be wrong.
U21%20Runtime_zpsnhhy9gjh.png

After the stepdown at turbo, the output is still much higher than the one high level.


And, coming to the answer: yes, you can reset the stepdown. Just switch off and back on the light.
U21%20Turbo%20on%20off_zps5fq4wjtw.png

However, as you can see in the last graphic, what you gain is around 10% of output. Such a small gain at 1000+ lumens is something very hard to notice by eye, while the light will have a lot more heat to handle.




My thoughts
The U21 is a relatively compact thrower with a big and bright spill with just a couple of rings in the beam (you can see them in the pics). Fit and finish are great (I love the matte black anodization).
The U21 looks bigger in the pics than in the hand. The electronic switch helps reducing the length of the light. The light will I fit in a big pocket of a winter jacket, in a funnypack...
The electronic switch at the head of the light allows to turn on, operate and turn the light off without moving your hand on the light.
The highly driven driver gives the light a lot of output (I found Manker's spec to underestimate the output of the light), throwy beam with still a decent spill, and great regulation. The stepdown are only present: after the 3 minutes at the turbo, and when the battery is running low.
Compared to other lights, the stepdown is very small.
It's good to have more than 900 lumens for more than 1 hour from a single 18650, if you use a hi capacity 26650 the runtime will be a lot more, keeping the same size factor.
The levels are well spaced.

Having a micro USB port for recharging the battery inside the light is always a welcome feature.
Manker says it can charge the battery with currents up to 2A. I do not know how to measure this, so I will advise you to choose the output current of the supply carefully: if it is an 18650 that you have in the light, a 1 Amps charger will be fine. If you have a 26650 battery, you can adopt power supply with more output keeping the charging times in reasonable limits.

The supplied adaptor is very large and the 18650s I tested rattle inside the body of the light, but this does not affect the light functionality. I used a piece of paper, rolled around the 18650 and inserted inside the battery adapter to fix the rattling. You can be more professional and use another battery adapter, or come up with better fixes than mine.
Accessing to strobe is easy, maybe a bit too much (I would decrease the delay for the light to consider two single click a double click, let's say a 1/10 or 1/5 of a second; Manker has already done so compared to the U11 and the T01 models (it is more difficoult to get into strobe accidentally), but I'll decrease it even more.
This light, as all the other Manker I tested, gives you accesso to a low mode and the last used mode that was not low. This light, as all the other Manker I tested, gives you accesso to a low mode and the last used mode that was not low.
I like direct access to low mode and a higher output mode, but I would like to see quick access to low, turbo and another level. Maybe adopting a triple click feature, or a double stage electronic switch could help "improving" further the UI.

When this review is published, the price of the U21 is 65$.
I find the price reasonable.
Manker said that they will release soon a NW version of the U21.

EDIT: 10 July 2016
Runtime with 26650






For you Candle guys, nothing really new is said in this video, but you can still admire the light moving in my hands while I delight you with my english.





Thanks to: AntoLed (for lending me the camera and the luxmeter) and P.P. (Beamshot location), Manker (battery funding).
 
Last edited:

laur

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jul 9, 2005
Messages
85
Location
The Great Northwest
Ladies and gentlemen of the CPF forums you have to purchase this flashlight ! This is not a hype, I am not being paid for endorsing this product, nor am I an employee of Manker. However, I do own 2 Manker T01 and one U11 flashlight and they all have performed flawlessly so far.

I also have the Manker U21 on order from Amazon and it should arrive to me about June 30th. this light has the best specs of anything in its price range (I purchased the light for less then $65 and got free shipping to boot). See post number 1 for all the relevant specs. Here are some of the highlights for such a inexpensive thrower:

Throw is 700 meters(125000 Lux) and Lumen output is about 1300 to 1400, Very small Mah drain and none at all if you unloosen the tail cap, a 59mm head with a polished reflector and the LED is a CREE XHP35 HI, One electronic button controls the flashlight, two quick clicks gives you strobe mode and has double gold coated springs on both the head and the tail cap.

Here is the Website on Amazon to order: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01G526CIU/?tag=cpf0b6-20

Enjoy,
laur
CPF member.

PS: forgot to tell you about the FREE charging cord so you can charge your battery right in the light via your computer
PPSS: Just got confirmation that my Manker has left China and is "winging" its way to San Francisco then down the coast to my place. (YEAH)



UPDATE
Received the Manker U21 today (06/25/16). What a great flashlight for only $65! I tried the U21against my other "heavy hitters" such as the Nitecore MH27, Armytec2.5 - 3rd generation and a Convoy C8 with an updated U4 LED and nothing came even close. On turbo the U21 overwhelmed all the other lights hot spots and still had a good size corona. I had to wait for about 3 weeks because the light is still only shipping from China but it was definitely worth the wait.
 
Last edited:

SG Hall

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Sep 17, 2015
Messages
1,096
Location
Sampson Flat, Sth. Aust.
Thanks for the review Budda! Very nicely done. [emoji106]

Pity they don't have double click to turbo rather than strobe. That's the only thing I don't like about the U11. Another great 26650 light hitting the market. This is the future! :)
 

Budda

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 30, 2009
Messages
590
Location
Italy
A member on another forum asked if I could bypass the stepdown by turning the light off and on again.
I did some test and graphs. But I got very different results from my previous runtime graph: the stepdown is very very low.
The Turbo curve I get now is completely different from the one I got before. I checked the data log from that old test, and I can't find any error.
However, I tested the first 10 minutes of runtime at turbo 3 times with 2 different cells and got the same results... This can't be wrong.
U21%20Runtime_zpsnhhy9gjh.png

After the stepdown at turbo, the output is still much higher than the one high level.


And, coming to your answer: yes, you can. Just switch off and back on the light.
U21%20Turbo%20on%20off_zps5fq4wjtw.png

However, as you can see in the last graphic, what you gain is around 10% of output. Such a small gain at 1000+ lumens is something very hard to notice by eye, while the light will have a lot more heat to handle.




The main post has been corrected and updated.
 

boo

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Nov 10, 2015
Messages
85
Budda, what is meant by "NW version of the Manker U21" to be released soon?.
 

Swedpat

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 5, 2008
Messages
3,448
Location
Boden, Sweden
Thanks for the review!

I really like Olight SR52UT and actually wished that Olight would offer a 26650 option of it. And here Manker released a such one!

boo: NW means Neutral White LED. A warmer color temperature. And if such an option will be released I want to wait for it.
 

sidecross

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,369
Thank you for the excellent review Budda, BudgetLightForum also has a good review of this light. I will be purchasing this light very soon. :thumbsup:
 

Budda

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 30, 2009
Messages
590
Location
Italy
Runtime with 26650






For you Candle guys, nothing really new is said in this video, but you can still admire the light moving in my hands while I delight you with my english.

 

BLUE LED

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
1,922
Location
UK
Thank you for your time and effort in writing this review. I found the video and regulation graphs very helpful.

I have ordered one and hope to take it to the next CPF meet. :grin2:
 

Sicnarf

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Apr 19, 2016
Messages
7
Location
Terra Australis
The amout of information and literally....Invaluable insight i've gained since joining CPF is greatly appreciated.
Big thanks to all fellow members. Admins and just CPF in general.

I currently up to 1x manker t01, 2x u11's and have just ordered the U21, can't wait for it to get here!!
:twothumbs
 

sidecross

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,369
I purchased this light in mid July and have been very pleased.

I use this light as well as a Fenix PD40 as my 'go to' utility lights. :thumbsup:
 
Top