Converting mcd/lux/m^2 to mcd/m^2 ?

jmccormick

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
1
I'm trying to take specifications for units listed as mcd/lux/m^2 and compare them against other numbers which are provided as mcd/m^2. Just so you know that this is a real problem, here is a source document where you can find the first unit: http://www.dot.ga.gov/PartnerSmart/Business/Source/special_provisions/shelf/sp652.pdf

So if I have a surface which is visible from 180 degrees and is rated as either 220 mcd/lux/m^2 or 0.30mcd/lux/m^2, how do I find what that number would be in a more conventional unit, like mcd/m^2?
 

Enderman

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
328
Location
Vancouver, Canada
Does mcd/lux/m^2 even make sense?
cd and lux are basically the exact same thing, only difference is that lux can be measured at any distance and "cd" is specifically at 1m.
If you have lux and cd and you divide them by eachother you get no units, which is meaningless...
Just like meters / meters = no units.
 

ssanasisredna

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
457
I'm trying to take specifications for units listed as mcd/lux/m^2 and compare them against other numbers which are provided as mcd/m^2. Just so you know that this is a real problem, here is a source document where you can find the first unit: http://www.dot.ga.gov/PartnerSmart/Business/Source/special_provisions/shelf/sp652.pdf

So if I have a surface which is visible from 180 degrees and is rated as either 220 mcd/lux/m^2 or 0.30mcd/lux/m^2, how do I find what that number would be in a more conventional unit, like mcd/m^2?

The first measure mcd/lux/m^2 is a measure of retroreflectivity, i.e. how much light will be reflected at a given illuminance. The second measure mcd/m^2 is a luminance value (also called nits when done as candela/m2). You cannot convert between the two as they are used to measure completely different things.

-----
meters / meter is not meaningless, it is unit less or in otherwise a ratio which has meaning.
 
Last edited:

ssanasisredna

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
457
"meaningless" as in "it does not mean anything in the physical world"

10m is a distance

10 is... a number? a shoe size? a number of potatoes?
Get my point?

I get your point it just is not a good one.

Ratios matter and they have a physical interpretation and they are dimensionless.

The ops question is a prime example.
 
Top