Test/review of Charger Nitecore SC2, updated version

HKJ

Flashaholic
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
9,715
Location
Copenhagen, Denmark
[size=+3]Charger Nitecore SC2, updated version[/size]

DSC_5424.jpg


DSC_5427.jpg
DSC_5428.jpg


The SC2 charger is a new model from Nitecore with support for higher charge currents and larger cells, it supports 3 LiIon voltages and NiMH cells. First test I did on this charger failed, Nitecore changed some details and have sent a new one to me. I hope this fixes all the problems with the charger.
The review will be based on the failed review, but with new tests and adjusted remarks.



The cardboard box lists lot of specifications, battery types and features.

DSC_5422.jpg


The box contains the charger, a mains cable, manual and a warranty card.

DSC_5431.jpg


The charger has two power connectors, one for mains input (100-240VAC 50/60Hz) and one for 12 VDC input.
There is also a usb output connector, this is not a power bank, but mains powered usb output.

DSC_5429.jpg


The charger has a new user interface with two buttons and 16 blue leds.
The user interface is a bit special, usual it will select current depending on battery length and chemistry, and either 1.2V or 4.2V depending on battery voltage, but it can be overridden.
To change voltage or current the button above that slot must be pressed shortly, next hold the C or V button down to select (Look at leds) and release when the correct value is shown. Press again shortly on the button above the slot or wait for timeout.

DSC_5435.jpg


The protection plastic over the display lists the voltage and currents that they signify when adjusting settings.

DSC_5438.jpg


It is important to remember the values, the plastic do easily peel off.

DSC_5439.jpg



DSC_5432.jpg
DSC_5433.jpg


The slots uses the usual construction and works well. They can handle batteries from 27mm to 70mm long.
This excludes some of the longest batteries, especially some protected 26650. Notice the long bar at the plus end, due to this the charger can handle anything up to D or 32xxx size.

supportedBatteryTypes.png


supportedBatterySizes.png
DSC_6297.jpg
DSC_6298.jpg
DSC_6299.jpg
DSC_6300.jpg


DSC_6301.jpg
DSC_6302.jpg
DSC_6303.jpg
DSC_6304.jpg
DSC_6305.jpg

DSC_6306.jpg
DSC_6307.jpg
DSC_6308.jpg
DSC_6309.jpg


Minimum current is 0.5A, this is a bit high for 10440 cells.
The charger can handle 70 mm long batteries, inclusive flat top cells.



[size=+2]Measurements[/size]


  • Power consumption when idle is 1.4 watt
  • Will charge a LiIon with 0.15mA when charging is finished.
  • Will discharge a NiMH with 0.15mA when not powered
  • Will discharge a LiIon with 0.7mA when not powered
  • Change between long/short cell at around 58mm
  • Below 0.8V the charger will report error (All leds flashing) and charge with about 1mA.
  • Above 0.8V regular charging is used.
  • Will assume LiIon above 2.0V
  • Charger will not restart if battery voltage drops.
  • Total charge current is 5A
  • Max. charge current for a cell is 3A with long LiIon, 2A with short LiIon, 2A with NiMH.
  • Default charge current for a cell is 2A with long LiIon, 0.5A with short LiIon, 0.5A with short NiMH and 1A with long NiMH.
  • Usb output shares power with slot #2, i.e. when charging in slot #2 usb output is off
  • Power cycling and insertion of a battery will restart charging.


[size=+1]4.2V LiIon charging[/size]

Nitecore%20SC2%202A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231.png


Default charge current is 2A with about 250mA termination for long cells, this may be fine for some high current cells, but is a bit high for many other cells. The curve is CC/CV.

Nitecore%20SC2%202A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232.png


Second slot works the same way.

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231.png


It is possible to reduce charge current, here I am using 1A, but the termination is still around 250mA.

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231.png

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231.png

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231.png


These cell are also charged without problems, but the final voltage is a bit on the low side due to the high termination current.

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231.png

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231.png


With 0.5A charge current the termination drops to 150mA, this is not low enough to charge small batteries fully.

Nitecore%20SC2%202A%20%282xSA18650-33%29.png


Here I am charging two batteries at 2A.

Nitecore%20SC2%203A%20%282xAWT18650-30%29.png


Maximum charge current is 3A+2A.

Nitecore%20SC2%203A%2012V%20%282xAWT18650-30%29.png


This requires a bit above 2A from 12V

Temp3933.png


M1: 47,5°C, M2: 44,5°C, M3: 81,4°C, M4: 60,4°C, M5: 63,9°C, HS1: 84,2°C
These photos are from a 3A+2A charge, that is some of the reason for the warm batteries.

Temp3933.png


M1: 67,2°C, HS1: 94,3°C
The charger gets hot inside.

PowerOnLiIon.png


The charger starts very fast.

CurrentChangeLiIon.png


It is possible to change current at any time during a charge. The first time I waited for timeout, the other times I did a quick press to activate the selected current.



[size=+1]3.6V LiIon charging (LiFePO4)[/size]

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%2818650-LiFePO4%29%20%231.png


Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28SO14500-LiFePO4%29%20%231.png


The charger uses a constant current only charge algorithm for LiFePO4 cells with a fairly high termination voltage.



[size=+1]4.35V LiIon charging[/size]

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%28LG18650-30%29%20%231.png


The 4.35V charging (Marked as 4.3V) has the correct voltage, but again it has too high termination current.



[size=+1]NiMH charging[/size]

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231.png


The charger uses a -dv/dt termination on NiMH, it is a bit slow terminating.

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28eneloop%29%20%232.png


It is the same on the second channel.

Nitecore%20SC2%201A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231.png


The charging is again slow to terminate at 1A, this means the cells get rather warm.

Nitecore%20SC2%202A%20%28eneloop%29%20%231.png


At 2A the charger sometimes terminates premature, I suspect it is due to my sense resistor (It worked fine when I did the IR photos).

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28eneloopXX%29%20%231.png

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231.png

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28powerex%29%20%231.png


At the 0.5A charge current it charges all 3 high capacity cells fine.

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231.png


The AAA is over charged due to the slow termination.

Nitecore%20SC2%200.5A%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231.png


The charger needs about 1 hour to detect a full cell, this is not very impressive.

Nitecore%20SC2%202A%20%282xeneloop%29.png


This charge at 2A is terminated way too early, my test setup may be part of the reason.

Nitecore%20SC2%202A%2012V%20%282xeneloop%29.png


This time the 2A charge worked fine. The slow termination heats the batteries significantly.

Temp3929.png


M1: 51,0°C, M2: 58,1°C, M3: 62,5°C, M4: 52,1°C, HS1: 74,3°C
The temperature is fairly high, but I am also charging at 2A.

Temp3929.png


M1: 59,3°C, HS1: 68,8°C

PowerOnNiMH.png


The charger starts very fast.

CurrentChangeNiMH.png


It is possible to change current at any time during a charge. The first time I waited for timeout, the other times I did a quick press to activate the selected current.




[size=+1]USB output[/size]


  • Usb output shares power with slot #2, i.e. when charging in slot #2 usb output is off
  • Usb output is coded as usb charger (DCP)


Nitecore%20SC2%20load%20sweep.png


The output do not have an obvious current limit, it just drops slowly with increasing current.

Nitecore%20SC2%20load%20test.png


There is no problem maintaining the rated 2A current.
The temperature photos below are taken between 30 minutes and 60 minutes into the one hour test.

Temp3939.png


M1: 50,1°C, M2: 49,6°C, HS1: 61,3°C

Temp3940.png


M1: 58,5°C, M2: 49,1°C, HS1: 71,6°C

Temp3941.png


HS1: 56,4°C

10ohm.png


Noise is 63mV rms and 360mVpp, this is a acceptable value.

2ohm.png


Noise is 45mV rms and 290mVpp


Testing with 2830 volt and 4242 volt between mains and low volt side, did not show any safety problems.



[size=+2]Conclusion[/size]

With this update Nitecore has mostly fixed the charger. The charger still has good and bad points, but nothing really bad.

Good points:

  • Automatic current/voltage selection.
  • Manual override for current selection.
  • Can handle very large cells.
  • Can charger fairly fast.
  • Use the correct charge algorithm for LiIon (It is just the parameters that is slightly wrong).
  • The charger feels solid.

Bad points:

  • Smaller especially older cells will not be fully charged due to the high termination current
  • It is a bit slow on NiMH termination, this adds some extra wear to the batteries.
  • The default 2A current for 18650 cell is fine for high current cell, but is a bit high for many other cells.
  • The current and voltage markings peel off.
  • USB output do not have overcurrent protection.
  • It may terminate early at 2A NiMH charging

The charger is good for high current LiIon 18650/26650 cell and acceptable for all other types. This do match with the box saying it is optimized for IMR cells.



[size=+2]Notes[/size]

The charger was supplied by a Nitecore for review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
Read more about how I test USB power supplies/charger
 

TinderBox (UK)

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 14, 2006
Messages
3,488
Location
England, United Kingdom
Not having a permanent lists of the voltage and current selection on the display and only using an removable piece of plastic is a major flaw for me, I turn around twice and get lost. FAIL

Great Review as Always.

John.
 

dazzleaj

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
26
Thanks for the great review.

I was tempted to get one of these but after your review I see it would not fit my batteries well. I really appreciate the great effort and professionalism that you approach your testing with.

Thanks again.
 
Top