Fenix Outfitters        
Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Review with X-Ray image: Thorfire TK15S (18650, XP-L2, 1050lm)

  1. #1
    Flashaholic* stephenk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Brisbane, Australia
    Posts
    637

    Default Review with X-Ray image: Thorfire TK15S (18650, XP-L2, 1050lm)

    Disclaimer


    The Thorfire TK15S was sent to me for review by Banggood. No other payment was received for this review, and I do not make any commission from links or sales.
    Product page
    $15.99 with code: a0f9a1


    Introduction


    Thorfire have made quite a name for themselves recently with an improving line up of quality budget flashlights. The TK15S is an 18650 tube light, using an XP-L2 emitter, side and tail switch with momentary function, and claimed to reach 1050 lumens. In a market with lots of competitors, lets see how it compares?



    Packaging


    The Thorfire TK15S arrived in a cardboard box. The package contains the flashlight, a clip, 2 spare O-rings, and the instruction manual. The instruction manual is well written, but with a few typos (“flashlight” spelt as “ashlight”). There is no lanyard, which is unusual these days.



    Construction


    The TK15S is an 18650 tube light (24mm head), with a tail cap that can be removed for battery insertion. There are two buttons, side switch for mode changing near the head, but not too close, and indented slightly to reduce the chance of accidental activation. The other switch is at the tail and used for on/off and momentary. User interface will be discussed in the next section.


    The bezel is smooth, which I like. I’m not a fan of the pointless “attack” bezels that are found in many “tactical” lights, as if you are at the point where you need to defend yourself with a flashlight, you are in deep trouble!


    A clip attaches to the tube near the tail cap, which is required to stop rolling. The knurling on the grip feels just right. The light can tail stand if required. Construction quality appears to be very good, with quality anodisation, and everything functioning correctly. The lens and reflector were not perfectly clean though - please take note Thorfire.


    There are springs as both ends of the battery tube which allows for flat top unprotected batteries. Protected Sanyo/Panasonic GA cells (Blazar 3500mAh raised top 18.65mm x 67.3mm) fitted with no issues. In fact there was some wiggle room, so most “obese” protected batteries should fit. Reverse polarity detection was tested to work. There is low battery warning (light flashes below 2.8V), but low battery protection/cut-off is not documented, thus I would advise using protected batteries in this light that can handle more than 4A current. (e.g. protected Sanyo NCR18650GAs). I wasn’t game to ruin an unprotected cell to test for low voltage protection!






    User Interface


    There are two switches. The side switch is used to cycle through modes in the order:
    Moon>Low>Mid>High>Mid>Low>Moon.
    I really like this up and down mode order as it avoids the sudden drop from high to low (or vice versa). The light has mode memory, so will remember the previously used mode (including strobe and bike) when turned on, or momentary used.


    Double click when on will access strobe mode which varies between two frequencies (?5Hz and 10Hz). Long press when on will activate bike flash mode, which has 3 flash bursts each second. Single press will return back to the previously memorised mode, or turning off will memorise the flashy mode.


    The forward-clicky tail switch allows for momentary, and on/off. This is very useful if you want a short burst on light, and being able to use momentary in any normal mode (not just high) is very useful for some specialist uses.


    Being into light painting photography, I really like this user interface due to the ability to easily switch between high and strobe and back again, memory mode, and ability to use momentary for any memorised mode. A video showing the user interface is below:




    The light can be physically locked out by slightly unscrewing the tail cap.


    Output, Runtimes, and Beam


    The outputs and runtimes are as follows (measured using protected Sanyo NCR18650GA 3500mAh):
    HIGH
    Claimed - 1050lm 50min
    Measured - 1100lm@30secs, 1050lm@2.5mins. Note: 3min step-down timer
    Runtime theoretical, as heat would prevent continuous test.
    MED
    Claimed - 500lm 50min
    Measured - 500lm@30secs, 450lm@29mins, 200lm@4hr, Note: 30min step-down timer
    After 4hrs 20mins runtime (returned to medium mode immediately after each step down), battery voltage was 3.22V, with subsequent 3023mAh charge. Thus >5hrs runtime may be possible.
    LOW
    Claimed - 100lm 5h
    Measured - 50lm@30secs and 30mins.
    Runtime still to be tested, but will be far more than claimed figure.
    MOON
    Claimed - 1lm 360h
    Measured - 1lm @30secs and 30mins.
    Runtime to be tested when I have a spare fortnight!


    The high mode steps down at 3 minutes to medium. The medium mode steps down at 30 minutes to low. Both of these step downs are timer and not voltage controlled, and thus it is possible to immediately step back up if required. Whilst I’m personally not a fan of automated step downs, 3 minutes is usually sufficiently long enough for most requirements to be kept on high. The step down will reduce the likelihood of the light getting too hot in the wrong hands or if left unattended. Aside from the timer based step downs, the light is very well regulated at each brightness level.


    There seem to be some discrepancies between advertised and actual output in low, and runtimes for medium and low. Thorfire need to update this.

    The claimed peak beam intensity output of 11,200cd appears to be correct in comparison with other lights.


    The emitter is neutral white, which I much prefer over the more commonly found cool white emitters. The CCT appears to be between 4500 and 5000k. However, due to the “technology” found in newer Cree emitters such as the XP-L2 and XP-G3, there is considerable tint shift between the warmer yellow hotspot and cooler (slightly purple) spill beam. The tint shift may be a reason why Thorfire did not choose a cool white tint. Whilst this tint shift may be an issue for “white wall hunters”, in real world use it is much less of an issue (as per the outdoor beamshot) . CRI appears to be well above 70CRI - I’d like to see an accurate evaluation of the CRI for this light, as colour rendition was surprisingly good.



    Due to XP-L2 emitter, smooth reflector, and small head, the beam is well balanced between flood and throw. The spill beam is much narrower and more intense than a Convoy S2+ with XM-L2/OP reflector 18650 tube light, and almost as narrow and just as intense as a Convoy S2+ with XP-L HI/SMO reflector.


    The comparison beam shots below have Convoy S2+ Desert Tan on left, and Thorfire TK15S on right (note: neither lights are on high, so this is for beam profile comparison only).





    PWM could not be detected on video, or during long exposure photos in any mode. So the light is either constant current, or the PWM is very fast.

    Outdoor beam shot - high mode, f/5.6, 4sec, ISO400


    Some light painting photos using the Thorfire TK15S (note: the horrible purple starburst is from a ledlenser P7.2)




    Conclusion


    Things I liked:
    Good build quality
    Momentary functionality can work with any memorised mode
    Unique up and down mode order
    Flashy modes out of normal mode cycle (requred double click or long press to activate).
    Good initial output and lux for a 18650 tube light
    Step down not excessively fast (3 mins)
    Moonlight mode
    Accepts wide range of protected and unprotected 18650 batteries (protected Sanyo/Panasonic GA’s recommended).
    Neutral white emitter as standard
    Smooth bezel


    Things I didn’t like:
    No USB charging or battery check functionality (I’m being very picky at this price point)
    Significant tint shift due to newer Cree LED technology
    Lack of accessories and tint options
    Errors in manual and output/runtime specifications


    The Thorfire TK15S is fantastic budget tube light. It stands out from the budget crowd with a unique user interface with up-down-up-down mode order, and momentary bursts of light possible in all modes. The neutral white emitter also stands out from the usual cool white fare. The 3 minute step down from high makes this light suitable for non-flashlight experts. Due to the useful momentary function, the Thorfire TK15S will definitely be staying in my camera bag when I’m out taking night photography!


    Note: The reviewed Thorfire TK15S is different to the TK15 (no “S”) which does not have the tail switch and momentary functionality.
    Last edited by stephenk; 09-07-2017 at 05:24 AM.

  2. #2
    Flashaholic* stephenk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Brisbane, Australia
    Posts
    637

    Default Re: Review with X-Ray image: Thorfire TK15S (18650, XP-L2, 1050lm)

    User interface video now added to above review

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •