lightseeker2009
Enlightened
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2009
- Messages
- 681
Is there a 14500 made that is tested to be dummy proof? One that will never turn a sealed waterproof flashlight into a mini bomb, or a house up in fire?
Nothing is 100% dummy proof. If you're worried about lithium-ion safety, then stick with NiMH AA or alkaline.
A protected 14500 is intended to prevent the battery from being discharged down to a level where the harmful internal reactions occur that can cause the battery to experience an internal short or other serious problems. It should also prevent it from being over-charged. Keeppower is currently one of the well respected brands of protected batteries, and their 840mAh 14500 battery, as I understand it, has a Sanyo cell under the wrapper.
Having a charger from a reputable manufacturer is also recommended, as they should reliably avoid over-charging, should use a slower than normal initial charge if the battery is discharged to an inappropriately low level, and refuse to charge if the battery is discharged beyond a level that can be safely recovered. Basically, a protected cell and a reliable charger should give two levels of protection. Xtar, Nitecore, and Liito-kala chargers all seem to pretty consistently pass CPF user HKJ's tests for those factors.
One more thing to be aware of: there is little to no formal certification for lithium ion batteries and chargers. It's difficult to impossible to find a UL or CSA label on these products, which is part of why it is recommended to have an understanding of your own of the safe use conditions for lithium ion batteries.
Many of us are quite comfortable with this after educating ourselves, but of course, the decision is up to you.
If you want to minimize your risk as much as possible, NiMH batteries are about as low risk as you can get, and we've got some good options now for lights that perform well with them. I actually just took a look at my Panasonic NiMH charger, and it is listed as Intertek tested, another certification lab similar to UL.
I have done a search, and no online shop in my country, South Africa, sells Keeppower cells. It will have to be an international order then...
If you look at other brand name cells, we do have Nitecore and Olight 14500 cells available locally. But a well respected member here have tested the cells, and have found the Nitecore in particular, to be below average. So I must look at something else. It would be stupid to buy something that was tested and found well below average.