Test/review of Charger Xtar VC2S

HKJ

Flashaholic
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
9,715
Location
Copenhagen, Denmark
[size=+3]Charger Xtar VC2S[/size]

DSC_2769.jpg


DSC_2770.jpg
DSC_2771.jpg


Xtar makes many chargers, this is a usb powered dual channel charger with display. The charger can charge with up to 2A for a channel, the current will depend on the internal resistance in the batteries. It can also work as a power bank.



I got the charger in cardboard box with the specifications printed on it.

DSC_2767.jpg


n the box was the charger, a usb cable and a instruction sheet in many languages.

DSC_2772.jpg


The charger is usb powered from a micro usb connector and it has a power bank output.

DSC_2777.jpg


The user interface is a display, two leds and one button to select what the display shows or turn on the usb output.

DSC_3080.jpg


When powered on the display will show all segments, the needle will start from zero and increase, I took the photo before the last needle was displayed.

DSC_3081.jpg


Charging one battery, the red/green leds always make it easy to see if the charger is finished.

DSC_3082.jpg


One press on the the button and the display shows the actual charge current.

DSC_3084.jpg


After next press it shows the internal resistance in the batteries.

DSC_3079.jpg


When used as a power bank the display shows the usb voltage and current.



The specifications are on the back of the charger, but you need light from the right angle to read it and maybe a magnifying glass.

DSC_2774.jpg
DSC_2775.jpg


The charger can handle both button top and flat top batteries.
The slider moves smoothly and can hand cells from 30mm to 70.5mm long.

DSC_2776.jpg


The power bank function only uses one battery and the slot is marked.

supportedBatteryTypes.png


supportedBatterySizes.png
DSC_3173.jpg
DSC_3174.jpg
DSC_3175.jpg


DSC_3224.jpg
DSC_3225.jpg
DSC_3176.jpg
DSC_3177.jpg
DSC_3178.jpg
DSC_3179.jpg
DSC_3180.jpg


The charger can handle 71 mm long batteries, including flat top cells.
The current for 10440 is on the high side even with the automatic regulation at minimum.



[size=+2]Measurements charger[/size]


  • Charger will use about 145mA from usb with display at full brightness and 32mA with display at low brightness.
  • When charging the last digit in the capacity displays will flash.
  • The charger will assume NiMH from 0V to 1.7V
  • From 1.8V the charger will assume LiIon
  • When charge is finished the charger will charge with 0.5mA for LiIon.
  • Charger will restart if voltage drops to 3.9 volt.
  • Charge will restart charging after power loss, or battery insertion.
  • When not connected to power it will drain about 1mA from a LiIon battery and 0.2mA from a NiMH battery.
  • Voltage dial will update after the charging is done.
  • Voltage dial is not very precise.
  • Charge current steps down if usb voltage drops too much and may step up if usb voltage recovers (Like when one slot is finished).
  • mAh display flashes "Full" when the corresponding battery is full.


[size=+1]Charging 4.2V LiIon[/size]

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%231.png


This is a nice CC/CV charge curve with a termination around 100mA. The mAh display is rather optimistic.
Display shows 3437mAh 42mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28SA18650-33%29%20%232.png


Here the voltage is slightly higher and the termination is around 140mA
Display shows 3107mAh 47mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28SA18650-26%29%20%231.png


The 2600mAh battery looks similar
Display shows 2730mAh 50mOhm (Discharge test shows 2481mAh was charged into battery)

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28PA18650-31%29%20%231.png


This battery is older and has higher internal resistance, the charger reduces charge current.
Display shows 3214mAh 179mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28BE18650-26%29%20%231.png


It is the same with this battery.
Display shows 2515mAh 149mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28AP18650-26%29%20%231.png


This is a new 2600mAh high current battery and it is charged at 2A.
Display shows 2902mAh 50mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28SA20700-30%29%20%231.png


This larger cell is also charged at 2A
Display shows 3164mAh 20mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28KP14500-08%29%20%231.png


A 14500 cells is charged at low current.
Display shows 889mAh 146mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28AW18350-IMR%29%20%231.png


The same for my worn down 18350 cell.
Display shows 204mAh 146mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%282xSA18650-33%29.png


With two batteries in the charger the current is reduced to 1A for each cell.
Display shows 3489mAh 63mOhm and 3112mAh 41mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%200.5ohm%20%282xSA18650-33%29.png


Adding 0.5ohm in series with the power supply forced the charger to reduce the current, but the measurement circuit is affect by this resistor, the cell is not 4000mA or 5mOhm.
Display shows 4074mAh 5mOhm and 3456mAh 5mOhm

Temp6056.png


M1: 34.6°C, M2: 35.0°C, M3: 36.1°C, HS1: 44.1°C

Temp6057.png


M1: 37.5°C, HS1: 41.9°C

PoweronLiIon.png


The charger pulses the charger current when starting a charge, this is used to analyse the internal resistance.



[size=+1]Charging NiMH[/size]

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28eneloop%29%20%231.png


My eneloop has been used a lot and the internal resistance is a bit high, this means the charger uses a low charge current. It looks like the termination is on voltage and a bit before the cell is full.
Display shows 1851mAh 103mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28eneloop%29%20%232.png


The second channel is the same.
Display shows 1538mAh 125mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28eneloopPro%29%20%231.png


The eneloop pro is also the same.
Display shows 2403mAh 82mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28leise25%29%20%231.png


The Leise battery needs slightly lower voltage to be full and termination works much better here (A small temperature increase can be seen on the black line).
Display shows 2438mAh 67mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%28eneloopAAA%29%20%231.png


The AAA cell also stops a bit before it is full.
Display shows 700mAh 202mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20full%20%28eneloop%29%20%231.png


Due to the voltage termination the charger is fast at detecting a full cell, it happens when it switches to full charge current.
Display shows 13mAh 81mOhm

Xtar%20VC2S%20%282xeneloop%29.png


The charger can handle two cells simultaneous.
Display shows 1719mAh 76mOhm and 1506mAh 73mOhm

Temp6070.png


M1: 29.6°C, M2: 30.1°C, HS1: 35.8°C

Temp6071.png


HS1: 36.4°C

PoweronNiMH.png


This looks similar to LiIon, but the charge current is very low.

PoweronNiMH2.png


Using a longer timescale it can be seen that the charger switches to full charge current after about 4 minutes.

ChargingNiMH.png


As usual the charge current is turned off at regular intervals to check charge voltage when charging NiMH.



[size=+1]Internal resistance[/size]

RILiIon.png


I wonder about the difference between the two channels, they are not calibrated the same when checking LiIon.
The actual measurement circuit is very consistent, but will give a too low value.

RINiMH.png


With the NiMH both channels gives similar value. Again the measurement circuit is very consistent, but actual value is too low.



[size=+1]USB output (Power bank)[/size]

  • USB voltmeter looks precise
  • When not connected to power it will drain about 1mA from a LiIon battery
  • Usual usb output will turn on automatic, and it can be forced with the switch.
  • Usb output is coded as USB charger (DCP)
  • Usb output will turn off after 40 seconds with less than 220mAh load.


USBmeter.png


When using the usb output the current is shown, it is not a super precise meter, but gives an good idea about the current draw.

Xtar%20VC2S%20load%20sweep.png


The power bank function is rated for 1A and can deliver about 1.4A with a full battery.

Xtar%20VC2S%20usb%20power%20load%20sweep.png


The usb output can also deliver current directly from the usb input, but there is no current limit (I stopped manually at 2.5A).

Xtar%20VC2S%20usb%20power%20%2B%20charge%20load%20sweep.png


Here I charge a battery at the same time and was drawing about 3.3A from the usb supply.
Efficiency will be low, because some of the energy is used to charge the battery, not for usb output.

Xtar%20VC2S%20usb%20out%2010ohm.png


Running the power bank with a 0.5A load it can maintain the output for about 3½ hours.

Xtar%20VC2S%20usb%20out%205ohm.png


At 1A the output is maintained about 2 hours, again with full voltage until the battery is empty.
The jump in efficiency at the start is when the display reduces background light.

10ohm.png


Noises is 47mV rms and 339mVpp

5ohm.png


Noises is 45mV rms and 360mVpp



[size=+2]Conclusion[/size]

The charger is good at charging LiIon, with NiMH it uses voltage termination without top-off charge and that means the batteries is charged slightly below full capacity.
The automatic current selection means that charge current is kept down at a fairly safe level.
This charger has a calibration problem on slot #1 for the mAh measurement, it shows way to much.

The usb output works fine and the display is nice, using only one cell means the output current is a bit on the low side.

I will rate it as fairly good.



[size=+3]Notes[/size]

The charger was supplied by XTAR for a review.

Here is an explanation on how I did the above charge curves: How do I test a charger
 

Gauss163

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 20, 2013
Messages
1,604
Location
USA
Slot 1 is very bad: up to 25% high on mAh and nonlinear to boot, vs. typically within a few percent for the competition. And 2 to 3 times low for IR measurements - worst I've ever seen. That makes it a very poor choice for anyone interested in an analyzing charger - certainly not "fairly good".

You'd think by now that these charger manufacturers would have learned how to implement a decent IR test - after all it's not rocket science. But no, instead of improving that are actually getting worse! Caveat emptor.
 

filibuster

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 27, 2005
Messages
205
I have a specific need in mind and this charger appears to have some functionality that would make it ideal for that use. I've been looking for that "perfect" USB charger that will work well with a USB solar panel. Most chargers fail to work with solar in that they don't handle the power variations that occur when being charged by a not so constant power source as a cloud can reduce the power output of the panel quite considerably and the charger won't recover. HKJ mentioned that this charger will "restart charging after power loss" which is needed for solar charging but the bigger functionality is that this "charger steps down the current if usb voltage drops too much and may step up if usb voltage recovers (Like when one slot is finished)." Its the stepping up that I've not seen occur in other charges I've tried. I may get a 1 amp current flow but when the power drops from the solar panel the charge drops to 500ma but when the sun comes back out the charger won't bump the charge back to 1 amp but will instead leave the charge at 500ma even though it has plenty of power.

For NiMh cells I actually like the fact that the charger doesn't necessarily fully charge the cells as that will extend the cells longevity giving me more charge cycles. The voltage termination for NiMh cells also means it should work better with a solar panel as it can recover quicker after a low power condition and it won't miss termination under adverse charge conditions.

Sounds like a charger to look at!
 

filibuster

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 27, 2005
Messages
205
Many, you can use my review list:...

Thanks HKJ for the reviews and for including in the latest charger reviews a section on how they perform with uncertain power conditions like exist when attached to a solar charger. Much appreciated!
 
Top