favorite t12 48" full spectrum tubes?

nitebrite

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
629
favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

what is everyones favorite t12 48" full spectrum bulb? chroma50 etc. i saw one with a cri of 98 but it was very expensive and at 3000k. so even though the cri is 98 i think at 3000k it might not be the most natural bulb.
the fish bulbs look great but at $40 a tube i think they are too expensive.


nitebrite
 

jtr1962

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Messages
7,506
Location
Flushing, NY
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

I have T12 GE chroma50s and T8 Paralite Maxum 5000s. Although both are 5000K, the GEs seem to have a slightly lower color temp and also render reds a little better. At $5.99 per tube locally they compare favorable to other full-spectrum tubes which frequently run over $15. I haven't compared enough full spectrum tubes to develop an opinion one way or another as to which is the best.

Philips makes a T-8 5000K tube with a CRI of 98, although it only puts out around 2000 lumens versus 2900 or so for a normal T-8 full spectrum tube. As an aside, anything 3000K is not considered full spectrum. The definition loosely means a color temp of 5000K to 6000K with a CRI of 90 or greater. The 3000K 98CRI tube you mentioned is probably meant to blend in with halogen lighting, which isn't exactly the most natural type of light compared to either sunlight or full-spectrum fluorescent tubes.
 

nitebrite

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
629
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

sylvania or philips make a 5000k 98 cri t12f40.
i have had bad luck with half-life of the chroma50's. they get black bands and dim a lot after about 1000 hours. and they claim to last 15,000 hours as i remember. i wouldn't want them after 15,000 hours thats for sure.

since no fluor tube really is usable any near it's rated life do you guys think that a cri of 98 is so much better than a cri of 91? because the chroma50's are $6 and the philips are like $20. the fish store ones are great but theya re $40. i have a lot of these fixtures in my shop so it adds up big time. i'd rather spend it on another surefire.

nitebrite.
 

jtr1962

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Messages
7,506
Location
Flushing, NY
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

What type of light do you have the chroma50s in? Is it a shoplight with a magnetic ballast? I've heard certain brands of shoplights, notably Lights of America, cause tubes to get only a fraction of their rated life. Last year I replaced the magnetic ballast in two of my older shoplights (purchased c. 1983) with new electronic ones from Home Depot. Besides eliminating 60Hz flicker, they should be easier on the tubes than the older magnetic ballasts were (although my old ballasts were apparently fairly high quality). No noticeable dimming of my chroma50s yet, although the electronic ballasts seem to make the color temp of the tubes a few hundred K warmer. This isn't a color shift due to age as the tubes appear the same color as when new on a regular magnetic ballast.

Regarding the difference between a CRI of 98 versus 91, I'm not sure if most people would be able to tell the difference. The only way to know is to try a pair side by side and see if the CRI 98 tubes appear better to you.

For both greater variety of tubes and also greater efficiency, along with the advantages of an electronic ballast, T-8 tubes are the best way to go. This is what I've been doing lately. T-12 is just antiquated technology, and as a bonus T-8 tubes require less space to store. The big three (Philips, GE, Sylvania) all make 5000K T-8 tubes with a CRI of 86. While obviously not as good as a CRI of 90 or more, these tubes are all very cheap in bulk (~ $2 or less), which makes them a good choice if you have a lot of fixtures and don't want to spend $6 and up per tube. I highly doubt the majority of people can tell the difference between a CRI of 86 and 91 anyway. For those color critical applications, at least Philips makes a T-8 tube with a CRI of 98, albeit at reduced efficiency.
 

snakebite

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 17, 2001
Messages
2,721
Location
dayton oh
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

the vita lite tubes are a 6 phosphor blend and seem to be the best replacement for sunlight.
i use them where color rendering is critical like taking pics,reading color codes ect.
unfortunatly they are no longer being made and i grab them when i see them cheap on ebay or on closeout at mom and pop pet stores.
the ge chroma50 is next best.
as for the report of early blackening you likely have a defective or cheap ballast.
 

nitebrite

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
629
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

i have very high quality rapid start electronic ballasts. these are not cheap shop lights. i thought however that the tube starters where actually much easier on tubes than electronic ballasts?
a couple of my ballasts are probably going bad though. hence the black bands. i thought it was the consensus that t12f40 tubes loose about half their lumens after like only 400 hours?

i could swear i knew of a majer company marketing t12 bulbs at menards with a cri of 98 about 2 years ago. i will stop by menards today if i go that way and report back what they were. i was looking on the web and cannot find these. i find rare speciality bulbs like this but none at large chain stores at the moment.

nitebrite.
 

gwbaltzell

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 8, 2003
Messages
578
Location
StL MO
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

[ QUOTE ]
nitebrite said:
... i thought however that the tube starters where actually much easier on tubes than electronic ballasts?
...
nitebrite.

[/ QUOTE ]
The terminology thats used is likely whats confusing you. Starters are the hardest on lamp life with one execption. A kind I can't find anymore called "fluorescent instant lamp starter" (will post a picture if anyone cares). These look identical except for a reset button recessed into the top. Next, in terms of short lamp life, comes the ballast called "instant start". These do not preheat the filaments, but just use high voltage to "blast" the electrons (you'll find the two pins tied together at the socket, these are also the ballast for single pin bulbs). The standard rapid start which heat the filaments and applies a voltage (not as high as instant start) at the same time. There was an older one called a trigger start which I've seen different descriptions of operation on. And one new one which is the best and may have different names such as programmed rapid start. These ramp up the filaments over about a 1/2 second period and then apply the higher voltage. The only main advantage to the other styles when done in electronic form is no flicker and more effiency. These programmed ones are the best because bulb life may be 50% or more over the rated and you don't have to worry about shortening the life of the bulb every time you turn if off and on. Ballast should have only a small affect CRI nor color temperature.

Edit: change my statement about ballast affect on CRI and color temperature.
 

jtr1962

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Messages
7,506
Location
Flushing, NY
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

[ QUOTE ]
gwbaltzell said:
Ballast should not affect CRI nor color temperature.

[/ QUOTE ]

This article indicates that waveform shape and frequency can indeed influence color temperature of discharge lamps. At the very least it explains why my chroma50s look slightly warmer on some electronic ballasts as opposed to magnetic ballasts.
 

jtr1962

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Messages
7,506
Location
Flushing, NY
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

[ QUOTE ]
nitebrite said:
a couple of my ballasts are probably going bad though. hence the black bands. i thought it was the consensus that t12f40 tubes loose about half their lumens after like only 400 hours?


[/ QUOTE ]

Actually, most T12 tubes loose only about 30% of their lumens at the end of their rated life. The black bands are likely caused by either ballasts starting to go bad or perhaps too many interruptions in the AC power (and hence too many starts). I looked at my chroma50s today and they have a slight blackening at one end but nothing that affects lamp output. This may have been due to the fact that they were on magnetic ballasts for the first few months I had them.
 

gwbaltzell

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 8, 2003
Messages
578
Location
StL MO
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

[ QUOTE ]
jtr1962 said:
[ QUOTE ]
gwbaltzell said:
Ballast should not affect CRI nor color temperature.

[/ QUOTE ]

This article indicates that waveform shape and frequency can indeed influence color temperature of discharge lamps. At the very least it explains why my chroma50s look slightly warmer on some electronic ballasts as opposed to magnetic ballasts.

[/ QUOTE ]

Thanks, I hadn't seen this. However, it is discussing cold cathode tubes with a mercury-neon mixture, were, to my knowledge, preheats are a mercury-argon mixture. It is possible that either might have a different an emissive state that could be triggered by the way the energy is delivered.

There is this study (.pdf) done at Lawrence Livermore that finds a large number of lines in both neon and argon that haven't been seen before.
 

jtr1962

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 22, 2003
Messages
7,506
Location
Flushing, NY
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

Very interesting article. Apparently the understanding of quantum states is not as complete as previously thought. Until I read the article I linked to earlier I was under the impression that discharge lamp spectra were controlled entirely by thoroughly understood quantum mechanical principles. Now it seems that understanding is less than perfect, or perhaps other factors not related to quantum machanics are at work here. Still, discharge lamp spectra varies far less with power input and waveform than does incandescent lamp spectra. Although difficult to estimate exactly, when I say my chroma50s are "warmer" on some electronic ballasts, it is by maybe 100K or so. It's not as if they look like warm white tubes when run on electronic ballasts. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif
 

brickbat

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 25, 2003
Messages
890
Location
Indianapolis
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

[ QUOTE ]
jtr1962 said:

This article indicates that waveform shape and frequency can indeed influence color temperature of discharge lamps. At the very least it explains why my chroma50s look slightly warmer on some electronic ballasts as opposed to magnetic ballasts.

[/ QUOTE ]

Intertesting article, but it doesn't say that it pertains to ordinary T8 lamps - It seems to be referring to cold cathode lamps with a Neon/Mercury mixture.
 

gwbaltzell

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 8, 2003
Messages
578
Location
StL MO
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

I never think of quantum mechanics being well understood.

At least I don't understand it well! /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif
 

snakebite

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 17, 2001
Messages
2,721
Location
dayton oh
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

frequency does affect standard tubes color temp.
i noticed the shift when testing homebrew 12v ballasts i built.the difference was only slight maybe a few hundred k but noticeable.
 

nitebrite

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
629
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

sorry to have skipped out on you guys. i forgot about this post. anyways my ballasts do not have starter tubes and say "rapid start t12 solid state". the black bands are actually light black, do not make it around the whole tube,occur only at one end of the affected tubes and happened to only 4 of my 32 tubes. i originally started them a lot. now i just leave them on 24/7. that's better right?

as for menards, they have verilux now. 6200k. 94.5 cri. depending who you ask the chroma's are rated 90 to 92 cri. the verilux is a better tube in my opinion but not better to the tune of three times the price of the c50.

i am not going to replace the c50's that are running fine to get 3 more cri at a higher kelvin. if i could get up to 98 cri in a t12 i'd do it. also, i did not mean that the output of tubes diminish in short order, i meant the color match accuracy does. the phosphers fizzle out for lack of better terminology. the saltwater fish guys(of which i am one) replace these tubes every 3-6 months if they are fanatic about the beauty of their fish. also i think paint facilities and such replace these way before their output is affected. i am not this fanatical about it. however all of us around here like the snazziest stuff. very few of us NEED surefires so in the same fashion i like the better tubes for bragging rights so to speak. i guess i should just switch to t8? the problem with t8 is the output. i'd need a ton of them. anyways, fluorescent tubes are no match for good incans,halos or xenon or especially led. why doesnt some comapny make something like a sf l5 in a ceiling can? that would be awesum! it would be worth the money because the bulb would probably last on the order of 6-8 years!


nitebrite.
 

snakebite

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 17, 2001
Messages
2,721
Location
dayton oh
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

for critical apps you change the tubes often.
since they use a blend of phosphors some colors wear out early.so the spectrum shifts.
unless you are doing something critical dont worry about it.
i change the reptile tubes in my boa cages every 6 months because the uvb phosphor wears out.
i use the pulls in other fixtures since they are decent full spectrums with a special glass and a uvb(low levels)phosphor.
and t8 tubes are more efficiant.
lots of 4' office lights use 3 t8's to get the same light as 4 t12's.
 

nitebrite

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
629
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

i finally found the tube i was speaking of. it is a philips colortone 75. t12 7500k 95 cri $10. is 7500k bad for general office lighting? the philips colortone 50 has 92 cri at 5000k.


nitebrite.
 

gwbaltzell

Enlightened
Joined
Dec 8, 2003
Messages
578
Location
StL MO
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

My opion is normally nothing "cooler" than 5000K and I tend to favor 4000K. The only use I can think of for 7500K would be an artist wanting to achive a very warm color in paintings, I think the main reason they prefer a northern exposure. Or growing coral in a saltwater tank. Also remember CRI can not be compared among different CCTs (color temp.).
 

nitebrite

Enlightened
Joined
Jan 3, 2004
Messages
629
Re: favorite t12 48\" full spectrum tubes?

i decided to buy one of the verilux tubes today. i figured i'd get one for my aquarium or python to try it first. gee it was awful! totally green. so much for all their bragging on the package. snakebite if you are still reading this thread, when purchasing tubes for use with animals do i need to make sure they do not emit uvb/uva? or are all the full spectrum bulbs safe even if they do not say reptile or aquarium on them?
i only have found one aquarium tube i like besides metal halide. it is the ge aquarays. it is comparitivly cheap. i do not like coral-life, penn plax, hagen etc. any good ones anyone can recomend? as far as the office lights i find the chroma50's to be best so far. there are ones with a few higher cri but they are over 5000k and i don't really care for them. either too green or too blue. in the aquarium however, i like it a little blue. but not green. for the python i like as white as possible since she is albino.


nitebrite.
 
Top