LED vs. Incandescent tail lights

NewBie

*Retired*
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
4,944
Location
Oregon- United States of America
I've known that LEDs are faster to come up to brightness than Incandescent bulbs, but didn't realize how much different they really were. Looking over a bunch of video, frame by frame (easiest method at hand right now), I see about 0.2 seconds faster, and really 0.3 seconds faster for the LEDs to hit full brightness. The circuit used on the LEDs takes 0.0002 seconds to hit full brightness, from when the brake pedal is touched.

So, lets say it takes 0.2 seconds. Assume you are driving 60 mph on the highway. There are 5,280 feet in a mile. 60 mph * 5,280 ft = 316,800 feet per hour.

There are 60 minutes in an hour, 316,800 feet per hour / 60 minutes = 5,280 feet per minute.

There are 60 seconds in a minute. 5280/60 = 88 feet per second.

88 * 0.2 seconds = 17.6 feet

So, an LED brake light could allow a person to <font color="red">stop 17.6 feet sooner</font> than with Incandescent.

But there is more. I've noticed that folks react alot quicker to the instant on effect of an LED vs. the slow ramp up in brightness of an incandescent. What this equates to in reaction time is unknown to me.

Here is a compressed video, sorry about the loss of frames and poor quality due to the compression, notice how the LED light, the top 3rd tail light comes on faster than the lower two normal incandescent tail lights:

http://www.molalla.net/~leeper/dougta~6.avi

(I had to watch the video about 20 times to get my mind and eyes sync'd to actually appreaciate it)
 

PhotonWrangler

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Messages
14,432
Location
In a handbasket
Wow, thanks for doing the math!

Yes, the LED's ramp-up is virtually instantenous, which is why they can use them in communications as well as video screens. It's possible to modulate the light REALLY fast. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif

I've noticed that the on/off transition of LED tail-lights and traffic signals is much crisper looking and thus more attention-getting, which is definitely beneficial in terms of reaction time on the roads. The highly monochromatic nature of LED light is also more noticeable against a background of visual clutter. At least until all of the other lighted "clutter" is changed to LEDs also!
 

MaxaBaker

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 14, 2004
Messages
2,260
Location
South Jersey
I've have read that the tail lights on the Maybach 57 (car) consist of something like 500 led's. I would NOT want to stop behind one of those /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/duh2.gif.

Wow. 17.6 feet could definitely save some lives.
 

ACMarina

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
3,119
Location
Brookston, IN
The problem with them right now seems to be a lack of good aftermarket bulb replacements for cars that originally had incandescents. My car not only severely limits the light output from LED replacements, it also makes the lighting control module think there's a bulb burned out because of the difference in resistance from LED to bulb. It's a fast changing market, though, and I'd expect some good LED replacements soon. .
 

PhotonWrangler

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Messages
14,432
Location
In a handbasket
[ QUOTE ]
ACMarina said:
My car not only severely limits the light output from LED replacements, it also makes the lighting control module think there's a bulb burned out because of the difference in resistance from LED to bulb.

[/ QUOTE ]

I ran into the same thing. Replace the bimetal-strip-based flasher module with an electronic one and that'll take care of it. The electronic ones are direct plug-in replacements and look the same from the outside, so they use the same mounting.
 

ACMarina

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
3,119
Location
Brookston, IN
That's where I run into the problem. My buddy and I put LEDs in his Tahoe, and everything went okay after we replaced the flasher module with a no-load flasher, kinda like you'd use on a semi or something.

My car has no flasher module. It's controlled by a huge black box of gadgetry and doodads, and while someone with a ton of skill could bypass the bod to make it use a different flasher, that someone isn't me by a long shot. The only option would be to wire in a resistor, I guess. .
 

James S

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 27, 2002
Messages
5,078
Location
on an island surrounded by reality
problem is that it won't save any lives because people learn to adjust to anything /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif Take anti-lock brakes for example, initially they did reduce fender benders, but over time people learned that they could tailgate closer at higher speed cause their cars would stop anyway and as far as I know they have completely negated the safety gains. Same thing will happen for brake lights, they will learn that they can ignore your brake lights for an extra half second or so and then when they are too close or you are stopping they will still plow into you.

for myself, I really like led brake lights. I don't like the PWM dimmed ones though,, I find them to be distracting as I look around and they leave the trail of flashes. There are some cars that are obviously current limited that really do look very nice.
 

PhotonWrangler

Flashaholic
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Messages
14,432
Location
In a handbasket
[ QUOTE ]
James S said:
for myself, I really like led brake lights. I don't like the PWM dimmed ones though,, I find them to be distracting as I look around and they leave the trail of flashes. There are some cars that are obviously current limited that really do look very nice.

[/ QUOTE ]

I've noticed that also and it is very distracting. It's so easy to spot an LED array that's being multiplexed or driven with PWM.
 

MaxaBaker

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 14, 2004
Messages
2,260
Location
South Jersey
[ QUOTE ]
James S said:
problem is that it won't save any lives because people learn to adjust to anything /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif Take anti-lock brakes for example, initially they did reduce fender benders, but over time people learned that they could tailgate closer at higher speed cause their cars would stop anyway and as far as I know they have completely negated the safety gains. Same thing will happen for brake lights, they will learn that they can ignore your brake lights for an extra half second or so and then when they are too close or you are stopping they will still plow into you.

[/ QUOTE ]


But if no one else knows about it.......

Then again, the d*** media will make the story public and what you have stated above will come true.

Don't ya just hate how they do that: "Marines in Baghdad know where Saddam is hiding and are planning a secret attack..... but we can tell you this because it is impossible for them to be watching this newscast on a portable TV in a cave." <-- sarcasm

^not a real quote.(just so I don't get anyone pissed.)

Sorry to change the topic.
 

Justintoxicated

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 8, 2003
Messages
1,151
Location
El Cajon, CA
[ QUOTE ]
James S said:
problem is that it won't save any lives because people learn to adjust to anything /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif Take anti-lock brakes for example, initially they did reduce fender benders, but over time people learned that they could tailgate closer at higher speed cause their cars would stop anyway and as far as I know they have completely negated the safety gains. Same thing will happen for brake lights, they will learn that they can ignore your brake lights for an extra half second or so and then when they are too close or you are stopping they will still plow into you.

for myself, I really like led brake lights. I don't like the PWM dimmed ones though,, I find them to be distracting as I look around and they leave the trail of flashes. There are some cars that are obviously current limited that really do look very nice.

[/ QUOTE ]

I was goign to say, if people would just stay off my @$$ then I would not need LED brake lights lol. I was actualy going to put some on my trailer but someone told me they would be way to bright. People really get on my *** when I am pulling my trailer because they know they can stop faster than me. I don't even have Anti-Lock Brakes! Hell I don't even have disc brakes all around I have drum brakes in the rear! So I think it might be a good thing to blind them a little when they get to close, that would surely teach them a lesson. Or maybe I could wire up a middle finger in an LED array to take care of two things at once /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif

IMO the best thing about LED tail lights is that they never burn out well, ok they might have burned out on my truck by now! But they arent going to to just go out like an Incan, which helps to avoid tickets.
 

NewBie

*Retired*
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
4,944
Location
Oregon- United States of America
Well, it's probably not legal, but you could add a third tail light, and aim it down. That way they don't get blasted unless they are too close...

In my tailight, I am utilizing 6 1W LEDs and a fast current regulator. I was going to use some faster parts, but got to thinking, and 1/100,000 second time for comming up to full current regulated brightness is plenty fast enough.
 

Darell

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 14, 2001
Messages
18,644
Location
LOCO is more like it.
You got pictures of that 6-banger, Newb? I'm curious how you're sinking the heat, and how much room you have. I've been building LED third brake lights for a while now, and I'm still not happy with the design. I REALLY wanted a Lux5 in red, but that just didn't happen, officially.
 

IsaacHayes

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 30, 2003
Messages
5,876
Location
Missouri
I have a lot of leds on my spoiler, and that comes on a lot faster than my regualar lights so that does help. My stock brake lights are behind smoked black lenses (they are like that from the factory) so I'm sure that cuts down on brightness. I do have a total of 4 bulbs in them though. Good incase one burns out on one side, there is still one bulb glowing..

The narrow angle of the LED 3rd brake light in my spoiler is pretty cool to see road signs way behind me on the high way light up at night!!
 

Paul_in_Maryland

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
3,191
Location
Maryland, USA
[ QUOTE ]
Justintoxicated said:
[ QUOTE ]
James S said:
So I think it might be a good thing to blind them a little when they get to close, that would surely teach them a lesson. Or maybe I could wire up a middle finger in an LED array to take care of two things at once /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif


[/ QUOTE ]Feel free to join me in being reviled in the thread, Blinding an aggressive driver?
 

bfg9000

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jan 7, 2005
Messages
1,119
The main problem with aftermarket replacement LED socketed bulbs is they are all just too dim behind a colored lens. A standard 1157 brakelight draws 2.1 amps at 14.4v which is over 30 watts. You'd need a LOT of cheap LEDs to equal that, which is the strategy taken by the car manufacturers with hundreds of LEDs.

For a retrofit it may be a good idea to add the LEDs rather than replace the stock bulbs with them. No load sensing problems and the two-stage brakelights would draw more attention, too. It's not like you will ever be replacing them so a drill and some glue would do the trick.
 

jtice

Flashaholic
Joined
May 21, 2003
Messages
6,331
Location
West Virginia
your vid explains it well Jar,

I agree, the LEDs are ALOT faster, and you are correct, the INSTANT on of LEDs catches your attention alot better than the rampup incans have.

I am seeing alot of emergancy, rigs, garbage trucks, etc using LED lights
and I dont think its just cuz they dont burn out.
I think they realize, or have been told that they are much faster.
 
Top