Mebbe you should wait for the 2W Luxeons to come out...
To meet SAE specs you need at least 96 lumens. You should build in some excess capacity (10% or so) to accomodate the normal degradation of light output over time.
The HighDome/Lambertians are the brightest. You're still going to need more than one LS though. Too bad there aren't any 5W ambers, that would be perfect for your lamp.