Aleph1 vs P60 beam comparison?

[akula88]

I know this is a bit of a throwback, but these are still relevant for those who still love the platforms :

Considering similar circuit and emitter -- maybe XPL-HI or SST20/40, which one would have better throw and beam profile -- Aleph1 or P60.

Physically P60 is looks taller compared to McR27. But I'm not familiar with the parabolic curve of the reflectors -- which one has better collimating properties. And also there are a number of P60 drop-in makers, which may use different types of reflectors.

 

[staticx57]

This question is far to broad to really a response. There is no standard P60 reflector and the definition of better varies by person.