My opinion exactly - the only problem with the prior bag was that it wasn't super well made, but I can't really justify the current 3x cost spread between the two bags. Maxpedition stuff is excellent, and I'm sure it's a great bag, but as an exact replica of the CountyComm bag, it's not so special.
Now, if Maxpedition really 'made it their own', and put sheaths, holders, pouches and attachment points all over it, so it was kind of a 'SuperFatBoy' or perhaps more of an H10 - like the biggest H1 you'd ever seen... I'd be all over that.