Fenix P3D Q5 Vs. TK10 Beamshot Request

[Doug]

Fenix P3D Q5 Vs. TK10 Beamshot Request.... anyone? Thanks.

Doug

 

[husky20]

here you go http://youtube.com/watch?v=IAVr3J8SE9U

 

[Doug]

Funny you point out that video... he shows (what seems to be) everything, BUT the P3D (never mind P3D Q5)....

here you go http://youtube.com/watch?v=IAVr3J8SE9U

 

[husky20]

well i forgot about that but he did compare it to the p2d witch is pretty close but there is other videos on there that compare and show both i have the p3d rebel and love it im holding out for the next gen of power!:thumbsup:

 

[1 what]

T1 on left (=TK10) and P3D on right.
Both on turbo.
Garage doors 15M from camera.
First photo 1 sec at F4.5 (Canon Power Shot S45)

Next photo at 1/6 sec and F4.5

\Hope this helps.

 

[Doug]

That's the P3D Q5? 215 lumens? I would think the difference between 225 (TK10) and 215 (P3D Q5) would be subtle....

 

[Mag317]

Hi,

i'm new. Just curious, why both flashlights using the same LED(Cree Premium (Q5) 7090 XR-E LED) and runs with two CR123 batteries but yet produce different output?

 

[LukeA]

Hi,

i'm new. Just curious, why both flashlights using the same LED(Cree Premium (Q5) 7090 XR-E LED) and runs with two CR123 batteries but yet produce different output?

The reflectors are not the same. That has huge implications for throw, which is what these pictures compare. The output of each is likely very similar, but more light is concentrated in the TK10's hotspot.

 

[Mag317]

Thanks for the enlightenment :wave:

The reflectors are not the same. That has huge implications for throw, which is what these pictures compare. The output of each is likely very similar, but more light is concentrated in the TK10's hotspot.

 

[2benlightened]

I believe if you watch the clip closely, I think you'll see that he accidently mis-names the P3D as a P2D. The light he uses mid-clip just before the tactical fenixes looks too long to be a P2D. (he does use the P2D at the end in his mouth). The reason the difference between P3D and T1/TK10 isn't subtle is because the larger tactical head allows the centre beam to be a bit more focused.

(edit) ah, should have read better, yes, more focused because of the different reflector/bigger head.

 

[husky20]

I believe if you watch the clip closely, I think you'll see that he accidently mis-names the P3D as a P2D. The light he uses mid-clip just before the tactical fenixes looks too long to be a P2D. (he does use the P2D at the end in his mouth). The reason the difference between P3D and T1/TK10 isn't subtle is because the larger tactical head allows the centre beam to be a bit more focused.

(edit) ah, should have read better, yes, more focused because of the different reflector/bigger head.

yes i think you are right.:thumbsup:

 

[Be a Crab Fight the Worm]

That's the P3D Q5? 215 lumens? I would think the difference between 225 (TK10) and 215 (P3D Q5) would be subtle....

I've owned both, the difference is not subtle. Now the difference between the P3D and P2D is what I call subtle.

 

[yellow]

the TK10 also gives more power to the led
(noticeably lower runtime).
That makes more difference than the reflector

 

[Doug]

I've owned both, the difference is not subtle. Now the difference between the P3D and P2D is what I call subtle.

Hmm... got a beam shot to compare the P2D (2 models, right?) to the P3D (also 2 models, right?) ?

BTW, what does your name mean?

Thanks

Doug