For the outdoors: SAK or Multitool?

[wquiles]

True. However, whether he was lacking common sense or not, he survived, which is why I consider it amazing, even if he lost an arm while doing it.

Like Mr. Doug Ritter said, hopefully this would serve as a lesson to others to be better prepared.

Will

 

[Deanster]

I saw Ralston on Letterman, and he seemed like an amazing guy - not at all the reckless and irresponsible type. I came away pretty convinced that he made a set of thoughtful choices about what he was doing, accepted the risks, and took full responsibility for getting himself out (with the help of a multitool) when he got into trouble. I don't think the ETS crowd is wrong - Ralston didn't need to end up where he did, but once there, he showed amazing fortitude in solving his problem.

I used to joke about being willing to chew off my arm to get out of a meeting. Since Ralston's story came out, I don't do that anymore.

 

[SJACKAL]

Agree with Deanster

I did just a brief read, but it seems that Ralston been through much and I guess nobody in his position would enjoy having another person whom wasn't in his ordeal commenting on his mistakes even though Ritter said nothing wrong.

I would think that Ralston is a great survivalist in his own right. Everyone makes mistakes or misses sometime and no one is invulenrable to unfortunate events, either greater or lesser degree.

 

[Blackbeagle]

This argument occurs every couple of years. Way back when it was the heavy Bowie knife. After, there were some who favored and pushed hatchets. Later, the late great was the Boy Scouts Knife. (After all, who fights bears and other wild animals anymore?) The late 60's, early 70's brought us the seriously misguided double edge, serrated dagger "survival knives". (Remember them?) Remember the heavy folders like the Buck 110 of the late 70's? Then the hollow-handle survival knives? Then the SAK's, the multi-tools... There is NO single one-size-fits-all choice! Never has been, isn't now, won't ever be.

Ask the proper questions: where are you going, what are you doing, what are your risks, what needs repair, what help/rescue can you expect... what is your worst case scenario?

If it is a short hike on a heavily used path an SAK would be fine. If you may need to maintain equipment (mountain bike, skis, hunting equipment...) a multi-tool would be necessity. If you are going cross country, flying a plane, going kayaking deep into an area, you really need a heavy sheath knife.

Tailor your equipment to your expected needs. Carry multiple items. Picking out splinters is NOT the forte of a lawn mower blade heavy sheath knife. Trying to chop enough wood to keep a fire going in snowy/rainy conditions is NOT POSSIBLE with an SAK. If you need pliers, you NEED pliers...

 

[Kris]

I have owned an Original Swiss Tool for years and it's the best multi-tool I have ever owned.

http://www.victorinox.com/newsite/en/produkte/index.htm

 

[Brangdon]

The Leatherman concept is to have a mix of full-size and mid-size tools in a somewhat larger package.

Leatherman have several ranges. The bigger ones are like that, but the Juice range isn't what I'd call "full-sized" and I wouldn't use its pliers on a tough job through choice. And they have even smaller key-ring sized multitools too.

 

[Gone Jeepin]

The multi vs SAK issue is debated every now and then. IMHO the SAK is for the user that needs a knife with tools more than pliers and the multi is for the plier with tools user that needs an added blade. I prefer the Swisstool models for multis and have many SAK models. I EDC a Swisstool Spirit and have a Swisstool X in my EDC bag along with a Vic Soldier SAK. I would be happy with the Swisstool X in the woods and would add a small SAK for toothpick, tweezers and straight blade. On the other hand, I have used only the Vic Huntsmen in the woods many times with no issues. The only way to really know is to try for yourself. Take one or the other on your next trip and see how it works for you.

 

[paulr]

I just haven't seen a multi-tool as that good a substitute for a real pliers (eg. vise-grip). I wish they'd make vise-grips from titanium, though that would probably cost a bundle.

 

[Deanster]

Brangdon - you are of course correct about the various Leatherman ranges - I actually EDC a Juice S2, which is very lightweight and unsuitable for heavy work of nearly any kind, but I elected brevity over comprehensiveness (rare for me)...

 

[pedalinbob]

We were camping a couple of years ago--stayed in a minicabin. The door was goofed up, so I went to my car, and grabbed a cheapie gift multi tool I keep in the glovebox. It has a bunch of tools, including a "hammer head". The hammer worked well to pound part of the frame back into alignment.

It wasn't perfect, but worked very well for the tasks.

Since then, I have the Swisstool, which I think I could do almost anything with. The tools lock, and the darn thing is tough.

But I still love the SAKs, and would guess one of the larger models would be fine for most issues.

If possible, I would have both.

Bob

 

[Burgess]

Two Decades Later --

This is STILL an interesting topic !


I carry *Both*.
_

 

[alpg88]

I'm a building engineer, i carry Leatherman with me al the time, it is extremely useful, but it has it's limits, I do not see it being much useful to install a sink, i mean you could use its saw to cut out an opening for a sink in a countertop, if it is a particle board one, or a plywood, it is possible but it is like washing a floor with a toothbrush, then you got 6 to 10 clips that attach the sink to the countertop, usually there isn't much room for a hand with a multitool there to move around, you either need a long screwdriver, or a socket with an extension. multitools are great weight savers, it gives you ability to do some work without having to go and get your toolbox, but It is NOT a replacement for the right tool for the job.
as far as camping, hell yes, i never go camping without one, or two, Leatherman wave+ is the best for camping in my experience,

 

[3_gun]

Within arms reach I have a Leatherman Wave, Wave+, Surge, Rebar & PST. SAK Cybertool 31, Hercules, a vintage Champ, a couple of Tinkers & a few others that I don't remember names for right now. So yes they're useful for whatever you're needing to do

[ forgot my LM Charge Ti ]

 

[Fuzzywuzzies]

I have a couple of the new modular GOAT multitools on the way, will be very interested to see how they go.

 

[yearnslow]

I have a SAK 'hunter'model, a Leatherman wave and a Super tool. You can't beat a leatherman outdoors.
I've yet to try any of the other makes of multi tool.
An Estwing hatchet, a wave and a good 6 inch blade are indispensable in the outdoors!