Hey Lux,
Why didn't you go with the Oppo BDP-83? Just curious.
- That Oppo is $500 vs. my LG $275. Not enough feature/value to justify that amount.
- LG has wireless networking, which adds a whole other dimension now that I'm using it.
- My focus was not on best quality BR performance. Still isn't since most of my movie viewing will be with upcoded DVD's.
My first impressions of BR vs. upcoded DVD are mixed.
No question that the BR titles I have seen (rented Ratatouille, Apocalypto from Blockbuster; bought BBC Earth series & Bladerunner 5 disc set) are noticebly better visual sharpness, colors, sound. I compared by changing input HDMI on TV between Oppo & LG, and had DVD's of Rat, Apoco, Earth (single DVD), but only had the Blade director's cut on DVD--not final cut which has more restoration which is on BR 5 disc set).
Having said that, the question is how much better is BR with these titles and setup? My gut feeling is that the BR looked and sounded 20% better, but there is no objective way to quantify that. To compare, I would say DVD is about 80-90% better than VHS.
I had some friends up from NYC, one of which is an actor & playwriter for off Broadway productions. He is 1,000 times more "anal" about anything related to movies/media that I am. He considers it criminal for anyone to get up or talk during the closing credits of any movie (even at home), until they are finished 100%.
I decided to play a trick on them with Rat, having loaded the DVD in the BR player and got past where the Disney BR splash video would display and paused it before we sat down to watch it after dinner. He has a BR, and was thrilled to find that I finally jumped into the pool.
So, I played Rat for about 10 mins, making sure to give lots of "Wow this is sooooo amazing....look at how beautiful and how you see all the detailed hair on the mice coats," and noting the sound clarity, and channel separation--to which he said things like: "See, I told you...now you know why I told you to get BR, etc etc."
After the 10 mins, I paused the movie and said how he was right about how good BR really is...and he was again glad I finally saw how much better it is. Then I opened the LG tray, took out the DVD and handed it to him. I told him not to be mad, because I wanted to see an unrehearsed reaction. I wanted to see if he would recognize there was something wrong since it was one of his favorite BR titles that he has played a number of times at home on his uber setup.
He (and his wife) were flustered, and didn't know what to say, but insisted I now put in the real BR version next, and of course he began a non-stop torrent of profuse adoration for the obvious superiority, claiming he wasn't really watching the upcoded DVD that closely. LOL! It illustrated my case of how I would sum up the differences between the two. BR is better, but it is not so overwhelming that you would know in an instant that I was running a DVD upcoding.
Other thing about BR is I found the loading delays irritating. There is a 20-25 sec delay once you insert the disc. Then the promos play. Then another long delay if you tell it to go to setup menu--before you get to the menu. Then again after you select "PLAY," another 15-25 sec delays. They are hard to get used to as compared to DVD menus, and much more dramatic collectively before you are actually watching a movie.
I am thrilled with this LG wireless player having access to Netflix, Youtube, and various folders on my PC hard drive for showing images while MP3 songs are playing. That alone made me happy I got this setup. I was very surprised at the Netflix free movies on TV quality. Close enough to DVD quality that I wouldn't mind watching a movie this way.
Overall I'm mixed on the BR issue, and have not seen enough movies to give a clear-cut opinion. Like I said, it is noticeably better than upcoded DVD's, but not dramatically better. I'm not disappointed with the BR improved quality...but not blown away by it either. Despite my now having BR disc playing capability, I will not automatically get new movies on BR if more expensive than DVD. Since they have no standards, I will wait until others have reviewed their quality at AVS Forums. The reality of watching a good quality movie is that you get absorbed into the movie after a while, and forget to even notice details that may be better on BR.
I honestly don't think I enjoyed watching Ratatouille more on BR than on DVD upcoded. It is excellent on both, and you get sucked into the movie very quickly, and forget what format you are playing.
On the other hand, the "Final Cut" version of BladeRunner is a quantum leap forward in quality, colors, & sound. I don't have it on DVD to know how much better BR would be, but it is one of the handful of movies that I would just want to have the best quality of in general. I'm sure I will get Avatar in BR, but there may be a new 3D TV technology that may be another version coming out later.