Icon Modus series - A Layman's Perspective

AardvarkSagus

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 14, 2006
Messages
1,474
Location
Lower Left side of the Mitten
Icon Modus 2

The Modus series by aesthetically focused manufacturer Icon is another shot at fusing high technology and practical usability with a look that takes flashlight design to an art form. The Modus 2, like its smaller sibling, with its seemingly cephalopod inspired design virtually guarantees it will garner more in-depth study.


Icon Modus 2

Meat and Potatoes

The Icon Modus 2 is not the same as every other flashlight in your collection. It is not designed to be the rough and tumble utilitarian piece that resides in the bottom of your toolbox just collecting dings until you need it in a pinch. The aesthetics of the Modus designs look like they would be completely at home with the silver jumpsuits of classic Hollywood future. It really looks more like the kind of light you would leave prominently displayed on an easy to reach shelf, where it can both look good and be used often around the house. Its polymer construction would likely withstand quite a bit of use and abuse, but I am not sure how well the appearance would hold up considering its current white/gray color scheme.

The skeletal tentacular design of the Modus series is nothing if not bold. You either love it or you hate it and there seems to be a bit of debate on that front. Equal parts of my circle of contacts fall on either side of that line. Some are completely enthused by it and others immediately express their dislike. This facet of the Modus line falls firmly into the category of personal opinion, and mine is that of rising affection.

The two modes of the Modus 2 are very well placed providing a decent gap between outputs. This is in effect the only difference between the two models in this line. The Modus 2 increases the overall output on both levels but at the expense of doubling the length of the light. The Modus utilizes the same circuit as the Rogue series so it exhibits the same gradual brightness step down on the high mode. I don't find myself running into this very often because I don't seem to use the light on High for very extended periods of time. When it does kick in, it is so gradual that I don't generally perceive anything, therefor functioning exactly as it is intended, reducing output to maximize runtime while providing no noticeable change in perceived illumination.

The Modus 2 averts itself from the currently traditional reflector design, opting instead for a lens based optics system. As I have said several times before, I am a big fan of lensing because of the overall beam profile. I vastly prefer the fact that the spill beam gradually fades to nothing, rather than providing the tunnel-vision inducing sharp dropoff.


Icon Modus 2

Constructive Criticism

Though the use of lensing does provide the Modus with a much more useful beam profile, it does lack one point that the Icon Rogue series had nailed. The beam of the Modus series is riddled with quite a few rings. Though these don't really cause much issue with actual use, they do leave serious longing for the completely artifact free smoothness of the Rogues.

The switch used in the Modus series definitely has a more solid feel than I first was expecting after experiencing previous Icon offerings. This time however it was decided to recess the switch most of the way. This location makes the switch a little more difficult to activate but does not at all allow for tailstanding. I believe that this switch should either protrude a little further or should be completely recessed. Half way doesn't cut it for me.

One last point I have found that could use a little improvement is the threading. Re-attaching the head of the light after a battery change reveals that the threading is awfully fine and relatively easy to cross-thread. This hasn't yet proven itself to be an issue but I am very glad that I discovered it early so I can watch carefully in the future.


Icon Modus Series

Conclusions

In short, I am the type of person who prefers rugged durability in all my lights. Quality hard anodizing is my favorite finish on a flashlight. I generally will choose function over form any day of the week. The Icon Modus series, however, is my guilty pleasure.

Provided for review by Paul Kim of Surefire and Icon.​
 
Nice review....would you be able to post up some beamshots of both lights. I dont own an Icon yet but would love to get one by xmas time.
 
Agreed! Nice review and lovely photos.

Aaardvark, can you give us an overall sense of the actual real-world performance compared to some of its contemporaries? I also like the look of it, but as a light, how does it fare with other 2AA lights such as the Quarks?

Many thanks!
 
I don't know if I can do beamshots of them or not. I am notoriously bad at those.

As far as real world comparisons go...you really can't compare them directly to most of the lights we see here on CPF since they are intended for such different purposes. The Quark AA-2 has more modes, a more complex UI, a rugged utilitarian metal body. It's brighter, but runs much shorter on Max (this would compare more to med/high). The beam profiles are completely different due to lensing vs. reflector and the Quark is much smaller than the Modus. The entire Icon brand so far (from my perspective) is aimed at different uses entirely than the Quarks. They are more of a mainstream high quality around the house light, where 4Sevens produces a durable tool for use in different types of situations.
 
Great review, glad to see we agree on these lights :) They look great in the snow!

Regards,
Tempest
 
Good to see your review and Tempest's appear simultaneously, and both in agreement about these lights.

They'll make the perfect lights for Flashoholics to lend to family members for general use, but it sounds as if many of us will be using them ourselves too.


Moving to Reviews...
 
The throw on these compares to that of a 7007 Coast light because of the TIR lense that it has. Even though the Modus 2 and the Rogue 2 call out 100L, the Modus looks brighter because of the distance. The Rogue LED appears to be a bit whiter than that of the Modus, but indeed, very nice lights. Good review.
 
Now see, this is why I don't like commenting on tint based on flashlight manufacturers! I just broke open a brand new Rogue 1 and Modus 1 and 2. Comparing the tints on the two single AA models, my Modus looks more white than my Rogue 1, which is still not as green as some of my Quarks, but getting there. That's why it's called a lottery. :sick2:

I should be getting my Rogue 2 in the mail soon so I can compare apples to apples and oranges to oranges, though the differences in light amplification/direction (reflector versus TIR) belie that comparison, at least I'll be able to compare a companies' offering to other products it puts out.
:popcorn:
 
Well, there was just a review of the Modus 2 on The Gadgeteer about this (here, if you're interested), and they also mentioned the exceptionally white light of the Modus as well as the step-down brightness.

I personally love how these things use easily-available AA's, although I will admit I'm not sure how often I'd carry a Modus or a Rogue due to the appearance, once the initial novelty wore off... but the light levels may be enough to win me over, assuming I can find these locally. Distribution in Canada seems to be an issue, unlike in the U.S. where they can depend on Radio Shack.

Do you think the tint's because of PK getting to cherry-pick the LED batches he's using for these?
 
Do you think the tint's because of PK getting to cherry-pick the LED batches he's using for these?

Not sure if that question was directed at me, but if he's picking the LED batches, he picked some pretty green LED's for one of the ones I got.
 
Top