Long Term review: 2C Maglite w/ MagLED drop-in

Monocrom

Flashaholic
Joined
Aug 27, 2006
Messages
22,677
Location
NYC
Several months ago, another CPFer posted some very positive comments about Maglite's C cell form factor. Until that thread, I had only been intersted in Maglite's D cell lights. My job involves patroling darkened office floors at night. But, I was never issued a flashlight. Also, the guy who was in charge of wiring the building did a very poor job of it. (Nothing like turning on a light switch, only to remain standing in darkness while the lights come on several yards away from you).

After buying a black 2C Maglite, I realized it was a perfect fit in my medium-sized hands. But I wasn't very happy with the standard inca bulb. Shortly after getting the light, I bought a MagLED drop-in for 2 cell Maglites. (The LED cost more than the light. But is definitely worth it).

This light was used, as mentioned above, for the last several months; on a nightly basis. I immediately noticed that putting in the LED drop-in did nothing to get rid of the donut hole. To get rid of it, you still have to adjust the light for throw, rather than flood. But once adjusted, there's definitely more side-spill and a brighter hot spot than with the standard inca bulb. Output is bright white, with no hint of blue from the LED.

This light is a perfect example of how an LED can have very good throw. I work in the widest office building in Manhattan. Floors are as wide as a football field is long. No, the light doesn't throw that far. But I was surprised as to how far the light could reach with the LED in place.

Some would say that only a rechargeable light is ideal for one used on a regular basis. I can't agree. Despite being bright, the LED sips batteries. Over the past several months, I've replaced the cells only once. And when I did, the old cells were still going strong. I just felt more comfortable with fresh cells after so much time had passed by. The forward clickie works well. It's not as stiff as it was when I first got the light. Often, I just use the momentary feature to apply just a bit of pressure on the switch.

I've never dropped this light, can't say how well it'll take to being dropped. But there's no filament to break. The light doesn't fit easily into the back pocket of a pair of dress pants. But you can slip it down the small of your back, if two hands are needed. You can even walk, with only slight discomfort.

Disadvantages: Same as what you'll find on all of the full-size Maglites. No lanyard hole anywhere on the light. Changing batteries is always a pain, due to the very stiff spring underneath the tailcap. (It's why I don't recommend the full-size Mags for elderly folks). The plastic lens gets scratched far too easily. Not large scratches to the point of being obvious when you turn the light on, but noticeable when examining the light. The finish scratches easily too. (But not nearly as bad as the lens).

Overall: I'd definitely recommend this light to anyone needing a full-sized workhorse. It's not a rechargeable light, but you won't feel too guilty as far as the lumens go; considering that the MagLED sips batteries. It has been trouble-free from Day 1. And everytime I take it out of my work locker and place it on the Security front desk, my fellow guards have this uncontrollable need to touch it.
 
I haven't attempted to do anything quantitative, but I updated some old Mags (4xD, 2xD and 2xC) with their LED conversions and in all three cases I was very impressed. The results were much better beams and better battery life.

And, yes, I think the 2xC form factor handles very nicely.
 
The plastic lens gets scratched far too easily. Not large scratches to the point of being obvious when you turn the light on, but noticeable when examining the light. The finish scratches easily too. (But not nearly as bad as the lens).

Happily recommend this glass lens, 52.1mm:



The optional LDF coating eliminates rings but also reduces throw. For the best of both, swap out the OEM upgrade for one of these:

 
Cool review, Monocrom! I too like the 2C size ratio, it fits just right in my hands, and can double as a whack stick if things get furry.

I've using C cells from a dive light that wouldn't light up anymore, and it has been giving me good light for over two weeks now. Just awesome. I'm sure these are great also for long run emergency lights.
 
I can also say that the UCL lens is the best $5.25 you can spend on the maglite. I have them in all my lights. Shipping is FREE too!
 
Did u have a different light before the Maglite?

If so how does the Maglite compare to the previous light.

Before the 2C Mag w/ MagLED drop-in, I had been using my Brinkmann Maxfire LX. One day, I took my Surefire C2 to work to compare their output. Saw no difference at all! But the C2 is definitely more durable, and the pocket clip is very useful. I wanted an LED light because, if used on a daily basis, I'd have to replace the Maxfire's bulb soon and the 123A cells even sooner. Before the Maxfire, I had been using my Streamlight TL-2 LED model. (It was also my EDC back then). But I needed more throw. The 2C Maglite w/ MagLED compares quite well with my Maxfire, in terms of output. But uses easier to find, less expensive cells and I never need to replace a bulb. Size wasn't an issue when I was using the 2C Mag.

The nature of my job changed, and the 2C Maglite became too big to carry. It has since changed back to what it used to be, but this will only last until a certain piece of equipment is fixed. Which could be any day now. The light is basically retired. So I decided it was time for a review. A nice send-off to a trusty flashlight that has served its owner well. The 2C Mag now mostly sits in my work-bag when on-duty, and in my locker when I'm not there. I would bring it home. But in case of another Blackout, I have no doubt it'll serve me well again.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

To: Everyone else -

Thanks for the information and the links. :)
 
Last edited:
I'm absolutely nuts over the Mag 2C form and am confident (sorta) that Mag will eventually remove head from rear and get a nice and really bright set-up. (read: heatsink with out compromising the drop-in ability)
 
I'm absolutely nuts over the Mag 2C form and am confident (sorta) that Mag will eventually remove head from rear and get a nice and really bright set-up. (read: heatsink with out compromising the drop-in ability)

I'm hoping for that too. But even with the now well-known intial drop in brightness. It's still a Winner, in terms of upgrading a Maglite. Thankfully that drop only happens once.
 
I'm absolutely nuts over the Mag 2C form and am confident (sorta) that Mag will eventually remove head from rear and get a nice and really bright set-up. (read: heatsink with out compromising the drop-in ability)

Reminds me of the MagCTower:


I'm planning on Christmasing upgraded 2C Mags to the whole family and I'm still spec'ing them. What benefit does the heat transfer provide, say for a Cree TerraLUX bulb?

Thanks!
 
Top