New Member, First Post - My First Lantern

LanternLover

Newly Enlightened
Joined
May 12, 2007
Messages
88
Greetings All!

I have been lurking in these forums for a couple of weeks and finally decided to take the plunge. I am from India but currently in the US pursuing my education. I find myself fascinated by lights of all kinds but I am particularly interested in lanterns.

I have had a long association with lanterns. I grew up in India where there is an acute power (and water) shortage. Until recently, all utilities were owned and run by the government, and were badly mismanaged. Power cuts are an everyday occurence, and in summer these cuts can extend to 2 days! The supply voltage is nominally 220 volts but it is often as low as 170 volts and in summer it can be much lower! As a kid, I spent my evenings in the light of kerosene lanterns and candles. As you can imagine, these are not the best solutions when you are trying to light up a hot summer evening. Later, when I was a teenager, rechargeable fluorescent lanterns came to the Indian market. These were cheaply made but expensive, poor quality Chinese imports whose working life varied greatly from one unit to the next. Nevertheless, these were a welcome upgrade as I had to spend many hours studying in the light of a lantern.

When power was available, the low voltages meant that the incandescent bulbs gave poor light. Fluorescent tubes would not light up under such low voltages. When compact fluorescent lamps first came to the Indian market, I was impressed by the claims of high light output and immediately got some for my home. As it turned out, the first generation of these had poor lifetimes and didn't work very well with the low voltages. Later generations last longer and have less of a drop in output under low voltages. The light was such an improvement that I have replaced all the incandescents in my home with CFLs despite the higher cost.

For the past few years, I have lived in a city where I have not experienced a single power cut, so I have not had the need for a lantern and have not kept one with me. Nevertheless, when I first stumbled across an LED lantern for sale on a website and saw the advertised runtimes, I was very excited. After reading articles about how LEDs are the future of lighting and are a major step forward, I came across these forums. I was disappointed to know that those claims about the runtimes are absurdly false but liked the fact that runtimes are still quite long and "bulb" replacement is never needed. Yesterday, I went out and got my first LED lantern - the Sylvania LED Mini Lantern from Walmart. It is a compact, good looking unit; not rugged but should be okay for indoor use. At first I was unimpressed with the light output but after my eyes adjusted to the light, I found that I could see across the room with the light. I put in a fresh set of alkalines in it and found that the light was usable for up to nearly 8 hours. At 10 hrs and 25 mins, it is still glowing but the light is not useful for anything except locating the lantern.

I am fascinated with lanterns that have long runtimes. I suppose this is not surprising since I have spent many years in the company of one. I request all of you to provide me with recommendations for lanterns. I suppose there would be some that use D cells and run longer or are rechargeable. Your suggestions will be highly appreciated even though I may not buy them right away because I have a limited income. Thanks.
 
Welcome to CPF LanternLover! :)

I own gas lanterns and mini led lanterns that take AA cells. For Long running lights I primarily use 3 or 4 cell maglights with led drop-ins from mag and Terralux. When shinned at the ceiling indoors they work great. Outdoors it's more of a challenge and I usually hang them upside down with the flashlight head removed.

Glad to have ya LL.

Catch ya later.

Patriot
 
Welcome to CPF LanternLover!

Nice introductory post. I myself am looking to pick up the latest version of the River Rock K-2 lantern (AA's)when my wallet permits. Another I'd like to get is Energizer's FOLDING LANTERN using four D cells with eight 5mm LEDs, plus an amber "nightlight". It resembles the flourescent version I now have and really like. I am sure others will be happy to suggest some lanterns.

Enjoy your time here on CPF.
 
Last edited:
Welcome aboard LanternLover. That's a great story explaining your interest in lanterns.

Someone on CPF built a dim-able lantern from some aluminum, and 4 high power LEDs. You might want to consider building something like that. I was tempted and I'm not even a latern guy :)

Here's the link: http://candlepowerforums.com/vb/showthread.php?t=129211

Cheers - Greg
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the suggestions. I visited a local Target before I went to Walmart and searched for a River Rock in the camping gear section but didn't find one. I found a Coleman MicroPacker but I remember reading in another post that its output is not nearly as high though it lasts quite long. I also considered the fluorescent ones but I doubt if they would last as much as an LED one, even on D cells. I didn't think of using a flashlight pointed at the ceiling as a lantern. I suppose it would work for most purposes but I really like the distributed output from a lantern, especially for reading.

I have been looking at these recently:
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0009IJC3E/?tag=cpf0b6-20
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0009J1EUC/?tag=cpf0b6-20
Anybody have experience with these and can comment on their brightness and runtimes, especially compared to the Sylvania that I already bought?
Thanks.
 
Welcome to CPF LanternLover. You'll find the River Rock lanterns in the flashlight aisle at Target stores. For something small I'd recommend the Energizer 4AA Folding Lanterns, also available at Target. If you are looking for the big Energizer (4D) the best price I've seen is at Home Depot (about $20).

Geoff
 
Recommending a lantern is just as difficult as recommending a flashlight. Personal expectations and needs are hard to assess as well as the performance of the lantern you're considering. You need to judge a lantern's effectiveness in the condition you most likely will use it, a darkened room, tent, outdoor activity etc. Do you need enough light to comfortably read or just enough to find your way around? I'd like to test a light in those conditions but it's unrealistic. Lux advertisements don't translate to any real guide until you actually see a lantern in use.

The current lanterns that I have would be adequate in emergencies to provide what I would call "useful illumination." They wouldn't replace normal lighting in any of my household rooms but if they would allow me to go about my personal business in a power outage I'd be happy.

That being said, I'm pretty happy with both of my River Rock LED lanterns, the 4AA LED and more recent 3AA K2 LED. I recently bought the Energizer Weather Ready 4D Folding Lantern for longer runtime.

Good luck in getting recommendations in this forum. It's a lot harder to do since FlashlightReviews.com closed down.
 
Top