Hey, thanks for your suggestion. Id do that, but i already asked them to check the color because they already sent me one that was off color, but just my luck this one is even worse. All my other nitecore is perfect too. I heard of some color differences in the d10, but my tribute is perfect, and so is the new d11 i got. I am indeed shocked, because in my opinion, nitecore is definitely more on point in quality control than other manufacturers. I guess if the color isnt flat black, then there is always a chance of mixing parts of different batches and then come out different. The color of the beam is also different, more of a warmer tint than the usual bluish. Thats not a problem as most of us prefer a warmer/neutral tint. Thanks for your help. I may just cover the engravings and paint it myself at this point. I see all the black ones in pictures online and makes me soo jealous. Ill buy yet another one if i can confirm that it is true black. I even asked lightjuction if the extreme they have is black or dark gray, and they can only tell me its darker than the ife1. So still not sure. For the record, lightjuction has an amazing customer service, its too bad I didnt get either extreme from them, otherwise they wouldnt have a problem helping me through this.