Hi Wayne
I'm totally disappointed
. I was prepared to write some very critical comments on one of your mods - and now I have to wait again another couple of days ...
.
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Daniel Ramsey:
... there is absolutely NO requirement to have voltage regulation to run a Luxeon for a flashlight ... <HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Hi Daniel
You know I do like these circuits just because they give me the possibility to do what I couldn't do without them.
In this mod as in much others cases too you are absolutly right: There is really no need for a DC-DC converter of any kind - except you would call this resistor also a DC-DC converter. And a resistor is also a kind of voltage regulation and current limiter
.
I think with the one ohm resistor Wayne has got an efficiency of 90% or even more. So it would be useless to waste money for a more sophisticated DC-DC converter than a resistor.
But in other cases a DC-DC converter will certainly help. Take a 4D flashlight. A step down converter will have a much better efficiency than a resistor. OK, I know: I could replace one of the batteries with a dummy. But then I would loose a 1/4 of the energy I could take with me.
Or take the 2AA Minimag or any other 2 AA flashlight. Of course you can use three N cells to get the necessary voltage to drive a LS. But N cells are much more expensive than using NiMH's - and they are not everywhere available. Only a booster circuit like the ZLT+ will give you the possibility to drive the LS with two AA NiMH's.
So using a DC-DC converter is just as good or as bad as using none - it really depends on the certain case and how you look at it. Regarding this Wayne is a happy guy as he can decide in which cases he is going to use a regulation circuit and in which other cases he will go without it.
Btw: Daniel, did you notice that nobody has to scratch with the chicken any longer?