Thanks for bringing that 8 AA Energizer lantern to my attention. I finally got around to ordering one and here are my initial impressions:
- It wasn't as large as I thought it would be (a good thing)
- It's only a fraction of an inch longer/taller than the height of a Siege or UST 30-day lantern, but being flatter, it's easier to stuff in a pack (though as yet, I don't know how tough/resistant to cracking or breakage it is)
- It's a little lighter with 8 Eneloops than the Siege or UST with 3 D-cells.
The BIGGEST advantage of the Energizer lantern though, is that it creates SIGNIFICANTLY less glare than the other lanterns (as long as you don't position it so the bottom edge of the acrylic diffuser is aiming at your eyes).
With either of the D-cell lanterns positioned next to the sink or on a kitchen counter, the lantern itself is a bright light source that you need to avoid looking at to limit its effect on the irises.
With the Energizer lantern, the diffuser works so well that it lights up the kitchen equally well, but looking at the lantern itself, it doesn't appear as bright/glaring as the smaller concentrated light source of the D-cell lanterns.
The flip up diffuser also allows 'aiming' the light to throw more light on a specific area.
One thing I noted was that the Energizer lantern produces a textured wall of light (no doubt due to the acrylic diffuser), but I only really noticed this on the white walls as the light is being moved. When it's stationary, I don't really notice it, but the Siege and UST lanterns don't really exhibit these 'textured' artifacts as much.
The Siege lantern does of course, have the advantage of being waterproof and submersible to 1 meter (and it will float in water in its complete form). It also has the red LED (although the usefulness of that will depend on the individual).
All in all though, if anyone is thinking about getting a lantern for emergency/area lighting especially indoors (or anywhere submersion is not a factor. Energizer claims the lantern is water resistant and will function fine in the rain), I would definitely recommend considering the Energizer lantern.
If you have other AA lights, the Energizer lantern's ability to run on either 4 or 8 AAs makes it an even more attractive option as you could use the spare AAs wherever they're most needed.
Max