Review: Manker E21 Nichia 219B (Pics, Beamshots, Runtime)

Budda

Enlightened
Joined
Nov 30, 2009
Messages
570
Location
Italy
I received the Manker E21 from Manker for the review.

The E21 comes in this cardboard box
DSCN3712_zpsaxoa3c2m.jpg

DSCN3714_zpsiiypdcoe.jpg

DSCN3739_zpscoquiyzg.jpg

DSCN3740_zpstcgs592b.jpg


The light comes with spare o-rings, clip already mounted, and manual.
DSCN3713_zpsuz2wmqog.jpg


The E21 is a sturdy penlight. It looks like an attachment for a rifle.
DSCN3722_zpsnvhgl6b2.jpg


Here with the Preon II Warm you can appreciate its bulkiness.
DSCN3726_zpsseqrnrpz.jpg


Group pic with other penlights: Acebeam PT10, Throfire PF04, Preon II Warm.
DSCN3725_zpsbc7cvvbt.jpg


And it’s built like a tank.
DSCN3732_zps8ktgtwem.jpg


Big strong clip that allows deep carry (love it), but it rotates easily.
DSCN3717_zpsptyd92qc.jpg

DSCN3720_zpsk9tl4es0.jpg


Mechanical foreward clicky with a metallic cover at the tailcap (no tailstanding) and lanyard hole. The metallic cover of the switch rattles a bit.
DSCN3718_zpsimzmoggp.jpg

DSCN3731_zpsfhbrvlzs.jpg


The head has a striking design and hosts a Nichia 219B NW emitter.
DSCN3724_zps6yrxaffv.jpg

DSCN3733_zps1xusp16d.jpg


The most distinctive feature of the E21 is that it can run in 2xAAA or 1xAAA configurations by removing the central part of the body.
DSCN3730_zpsfmtczm8i.jpg


If you run it as a single AAA battery, the light will be shorter and with a smoother design (less rifle attachment).
Here with the Preon II
DSCN3727_zpsww6jp3md.jpg

DSCN3728_zpsfghintjg.jpg


Here with the 1xAAA Lumintop Tool clicky version.
DSCN3729_zpsgp8ygthl.jpg


DSCN3735_zpswxg9ykms.jpg

DSCN3738_zpsci9ebbmi.jpg

DSCN3737_zpsbtdfhhkt.jpg



UI
The forward clicky allows momentary on.
The light has 3 constant output modes: low, mid and high. The light always turns on at low mode.
To proceed between the modes you can either half press every time the switch, and when you are in the desired level, fully click it; or turn on and off the light every time to change level.
After you went through low mid hi cycles twice, you’ll have strobe mode.



Beamshots
at 0.5 meters from the wall
I like the NW tint of this light, with good CRI.

Some tint and beam comparison with the Preon II Warm
DSCN4269_zpsnjdrvjfw.jpg

DSCN4270_zpssvr94ky6.jpg

DSCN4271_zpss6ryw3vw.jpg

DSCN4272_zpsxx1nqpte.jpg


Beam and tint comparison with the Lumintop Tool Ti XP-G2 CW
DSCN4273_zpsfvpvitaf.jpg

DSCN4274_zpshm3cyump.jpg

DSCN4275_zpszvcfbx2i.jpg


Beam and tint comparison with Nitecore NU20 CRI, Nitecore TIP CRI, all 3 lights equip a Nichia 219B emitter. All lights set at mid mode (around 20 lumens).
DSCN4292_zps2nopx8xe.jpg

DSCN4293_zpsqaubjle8.jpg

DSCN4294_zpsjzftdfpc.jpg

DSCN4295_zpsyaowx6h7.jpg


The tint of the 219B on the E21 is the most warm, I like it a lot.


Output and runtime
Both tested with Eneloop AAA cells.
Output_zpstgrxpyik.png

Runtime1_zps0pz5l8tf.png

Runtime2_zpsciarup84.png

Runtime3_zpsjcsn1pvh.png

Runtime4_zps6pizcw98.png




My thoughts
Fit and finishes are as you would expect from Manker.
The E21 is built as a tank and is to my knowledge the only penlight that is able to operate with 1 and 2 AAA without the need to purchase additional parts. Preon were initially available in a kit with 1xAAA and 2xAAA bodies, but not now.
I believe these are the 2 most distinguishing features of this light: design and 1xAAA/2zAAA capability.
On all my penlights and lights with a clicky type interface, I do prefer a reverse clicky instead of a forward one because I do prefer turn the light on and then switch modes, instead of switching modes by lightly tapping the switch and “confirming” the brightness with a full click. And that, I repeat, is my personal preference.
I’d like the light to turn on at a higher output than moonlight, like 5-10 lumens, because for almost all my penlight needs, I have to switch to at least medium mode or high mode all the time.
So, either changing the sequence to mid-low-hi, or even better IMHO, change brightness to 5(or10) – 50 – 200 lumens.
Don’t get me wrong, I love firefly and sub lumen modes, but not when a light has just 3 modes and one of them is a firefly.
I’d like to see the same brightness for low mode both for 1xAAA and 2xAAA configuration.

Thanks to: AntoLed for the camera and the luxmeter.
 

rookiedaddy

Enlightened
Joined
Apr 21, 2009
Messages
937
Location
A Place Called HOME
MankerE21Nichia219b.jpg

finally bought mine from a local retailer:

  • Overbuilt body
  • Nichia 219B
  • Available in Neutral and Cool white tint :nana:
  • Start in Moon mode
  • OP reflector
  • Transformable between 1xAAA and 2xAAA

Between Nitecore MT06MD and Manker E21, I've chosen E21. The Nitecore MT06MD actually have everything going for it:

  • Start in low mode (4 lumens)
  • Nichia 219B
  • Reverse-clicky
except the beam profile produces a donut hole in the middle of the beam (or if you may, an outer cooler tinted ring centering around the hot spot) due to the use of SMO reflector. For a light that's designed and targeted towards Medical Professionals, I'm in the strong opinion that SMO is the wrong choice to use for a reflector. I wish Nitecore would do MT06MD in OP reflector.


Btw, the aggressiveness in design of this Manker E21 reminiscent something that would came out from PKDL... :p
 
Top