It is my understanding that the item needs to be highly polished before the chroming process, in order for it to come out shiny (like a mirror). This was told to me by Fivemega (who, as you know, does a lot of chroming). Hearing this made sense to me, too, because when I was younger,I had a bicycle chromed and the insides of the split frame were not shiny and I was told that they couldn't get the polisher between the two parts of the frame (it was a Jimmy Wynert (Winert?), later bought by the Torker company. If you've seen a Torker, you know what I mean by the split frame (split top bar...actually, there are other brands of bikes that have had this design, but they are mostly ten-speeds)
So, maybe, if an item is stripped, but not polished, the chroming process will leave it with a dull finish. Nothing solid here, just what I think. I may be right, I may be wrong, but either way, I'd like to know the truth and see some examples of a non polished piece being chromed.