Spark ST5-125OW vs Zebralight H51W

[z_jbclimber]

Does anyone have both the Spark ST5-125OW and Zebralight H51W? I have the H51W, but the Spark looks tempting! Has anyone done there own comparison and what were your thoughts? I heard the Spark total weight is more than advertised, is this true? Is one more of a flood than the other? Thanks.

 

[ibu]

Yes, the weight on the website of Spark is incorrect.

My laboratory balance says:

104.6 g (lamp, Eneloop, belt)
64.1 g (lamp, Eneloop)

I use the Spark with a reduced belt, which means I had removed the over the top belt part.

91.5 g (lamp, Eneloop, reduced belt)

Because the Spark is my only LED lamp I cannot compare the beam.

 

[tedh]

I had both, but sent the Spark back because it had the weird flicker problem others have reported. I did do a beamshot comparison before I sent it back:

H51 on the left, Spark ST5 on right. Note the wide spill of the spark, visible in the lower right.

The new version has the XM-L emitter, which will change the beam profile.

I liked the Spark a lot while I had it - the memorized level was nice, and the protrusion of the lens away from my head reduced the glare on my glasses. I am looking forward to getting it back for a more in-depth comparison.

Oh, looks like the weight has been corrected for the newer versions.

Ted