I think that depends. S, B&D bought Craftsman to essentially try and put lipstick on an entry level product line. Their initial run of Craftman was pure Chinesium, and there was a lot of backlash.
They are now manufacturing a lot of the Craftsman products in Taiwan, instead, and it's a reasonable improvement for a mid-range brand, as Taiwan DOES do very excellent tool manufacturing at reasonable prices.
When Sears owned Craftsman, it was very much during a time when the U.S. had a robust middle class, and you could sell tools to these "enthusiast+" non-professionals. Now, you only really have markets at the cheap end and high end, and BOTH of those are wildly crowded in the tool world.
For many of us, this is why the end of Sears Craftsman was so cutting; it was the last option for truly decent tools at a reasonable price for a non-professional. Sure, the tools weren't AS GOOD as the ones from the tool truck, but if you accepted that, they were damn fine tools for their price (made by VERY competent companies). Sure, at the VERY end of their Sears ownership, you could tell standards were slipping, but for a good CENTURY, Craftsman really was a seal of quality.
Flashlights are a lot different. Sure, there's a MASSIVE market for the cheapest light possible to flood into Wal-Mart and Amazon, and there's a very high end market, but there's a fairly lively mid-tier of enthusiast lights. You're not going to have the market share of hand tools, but I think that's okay.
Brands like Peak and Malkoff still make lights in the U.S., and while they're more expensive than Chinese brands, they're not really that expensive. Titanium lights from China are often multiple times as expensive as a Peak or Malkoff. Compared to some of the "exotic" metal "enthusiast" lights from China, Surefire is downright affordable.
Flashlights aren't TOO complicated, and you can make a super high QA light in the U.S. like HDS, and it's still cheaper than a lot of the novelty collectible ones from China. Surefire has the equipment to make their own boards, and they have their own engineering teams, yet their newish EDC1-DFT sells for around $200 street price.
The U.S. is also a manufacturing POWERHOUSE. Many people don't realize the sheer skill and scale of the US knowledge base in manufacturing. I live in the Rust Belt, and we still churn out absolutely insane stuff at a very, very high level; extremely tight tolerances with individual part testing, etc. Around here, you can make good money in manufacturing, because companies pay for that skill. I was once at the shop of a household name F500 that made aerospace parts. The entire facility was cleaner than a surgery room, and the complexity of the parts they made were shocking; you'd think they were 3D printed. They only hired smart people with skill. While we have kind of a negative attitude towards manufacturing in the U.S., it's really the spear head of the STEM world; it's where the bleeding edge technology is implemented.
There's nothing stopping ZL from contracting manufacturers in one of the Aerospace corridors in the U.S. if they wanted some serious skill with aluminum. I think the difference is that some of the smaller shops (Malkoff, Peak, HDS, Convoy, Emisar) are largely small groups of people who handle the machining/assembly directly, and it sounds more like ZL handles the "specification selection;" i.e. it's more akin to a drop-shipping company than to a small manufacturer, and the final assembly is likely where they have an issue. Gene, Robyn, and Henry don't mind spending their afternoon assembling their lights by hand...
While we have kind of a negative attitude towards manufacturing in the U.S., it's really the spear head of the STEM world; it's where the bleeding edge technology is implemented.
There are some very good points here. I always tell younger folks that what is far more important than 'what you know' is 'what you can do with what your know'. Some may virtue signal about so-called 'STEM', but if one can't actually do / produce something with what they know, it is of relatively little value. B&D has little to do with flashlights, but when I read this stuff it made me wonder what happened to the Easton Md. facility (their HQ was Towson, MD) where I did work on some telecom switching equipment decades ago. It's been dead for 20 years now, with most of the jobs there having apparently been shipped to Mexico. Yeah, 'intellectual property' doesn't mean much if one can't use it to produce products. The U.S. system's talent production now includes few who actually know how to make things, and unfortunately things have been allowed to continue this decline down the 'brain drain' road to a point where, at this point, it would take decades to correct the course. Sadly, B&D is but one story, but is perhaps indicative of the process which has left this country, once a leader in global manufacturing, in practical 'third world' shambles status in the manufacturing world. I guess in a day when one can make $15+/hr. for handing out cheeseburgers, why do 'real' hard work in manufacturing?;-)
Here's the building:
Former Black & Decker building renamed
EASTON — Black & Decker hasn’t operated out of its former Easton facility at 28712 Glebe Road since 2003, but people still call the building by the company’s trademarked name.
www.myeasternshoremd.com
...and here's just a bit of background on how B&D has tried(?) to navigate through this sad reality, if you'd like to read it and weep:
Black & Decker closing Maryland plant, cutting 1,300 jobs
EASTON, Md. (AP) _ Black & Decker Corp. will close its Easton plant, eliminating 1,300 jobs and leaving the toolmaker with virtually no manufacturing presence in its home state. <br><br>Most of the Maryland
www.newson6.com
Personally, I'd rather get back to talking about flashlights. This probably belongs in the 'ptomaine kitchen' of the 'Cafe';-), but if someone's actually interested in Black and Decker, ......