I have one of these sitting next to a Sylvania Golden Dragon in my bedroom. I often get to bed later than my wife, and have tested these for a few months as low level lights for getting ready for bed without disturbing her. For this use, I just need low light so I don't trip on stuff.
I find myself using the Coleman much more often, due to the shield (which I always leave up) and the shape, which makes it much easier to find the button in the dark. The Sylvania is round, the button is small, and I always have to fumble with it.
It's really heavy on the artifacts, and I also tested it by using it to read in bed, where the shield was great, but the artifacts are way too dramatic. The Sylvania's light is a lot smoother, but they both have a lot of glare if you can see the LED, so I turn the Coleman towards the wall. The Sylvania would probably be good if I taped part of the globe to act as a shield.
There's not a lot of light from either. The Coleman's quit changing brightness from low to high (the low isn't that much lower than high), and I haven't checked to see if it's the batteries getting low. ETA: Yep, down to 1.1v.
These are earthquake/power outage lights for me, and while I like the efficiency better than the fluorescent lanterns they replaced, the light quality isn't very good. The biggest problem is that you need to be fairly close to them because the light levels are low, and the glare and artifacts get pretty annoying.
My neighbor has a Coast TT7105CP Lenser (3 leds), and it's a pretty superior lantern, though a lot more expensive.