Which 1800 mAH AA is best??

SubtleIrony

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Jan 29, 2002
Messages
42
Location
San Francisco
Which one of the new 1800 mAH NIMH batteries are best? (for both flashight and digicams)

PowerEX 1800
Nextcell 1800
GP 1800

or the generic ones they have at onlybatteries.com??
 
I have a dozen PowerEx AAs on the way from Thomas Distributing. They are supposed to be the best, but we will see.
 
You know, I saw that recent post (from some review of the AA nimh rechargeables...) and it seemed like th 1600mah Rayovac's were the best....
and that the 1800mah AA's weren't really that much better, if any...
 
If you check that link again, it's been updated. The Powerex 1800s are now the clear winner. I believe it. I've had a dozen of them for a couple weeks, and they're giving me previously unheard of runtime. I would use a smart charger, though, to make sure they're being fully charged.
 
Excellent article-that imaging resource one.....So would it be over-simplistic for the mfrs. to rate those cells in WattHours?
 
That would be the best way to measure the total energy stored in the battery, but as the article points out, it's necessary to take samples at regular intervals to get an accurate measure of this.

A simple runtime test with a fixed value load doesn't fully measure this, since the voltage (and hence current) both decrease as the batteries are being discharged. In other words, the number of watts is decreasing with time, although with NiMH probably not by too much. He says he takes data at regular intervals, then integrates (sums) his data over the runtime to get the total watt hours. Actually, he doesn't explicitly say this, but I know what he means.

It's also necessary to consider that batteries deliver power with different efficiencies under different loads. A larger load produces less efficient power delivery (I assume because of excess heat). So his fixed value resistor set up may not tell the whole story, depending on how "draining" your application is.

Then there's the factor of draining the batteries in spurts instead of continuously. It's a real consideration for digital cameras, but for high power flashlights too, since most people switch them on and off.

I can't tell you anything about these other factors.
 
Back
Top