Which EDC?

[MaxaBaker]

Hello guys,

I am in desperate need of a new EDC light and I was considering either the Inova X5 or the Nuwai Q3. I hear they are both very tough and very bright. Which do you people think makes a better EDC light in a general perspective?

-brightness
-toughness
-size
-runtime

That's what I'm really interested in.

Thanx

 

[JeffH]

I have not used an X5 but I can tell you that I sure do love my Qiii. I am using the Batterystation rechargeables in it and it's just amazingly bright for it's size. It's fixed focus has a nice hot spot with what seems to me a huge spill area. I have been keeping it in my pocket and find it to be non intrusive. Others report very good run times. I'm simply swapping out the recargeables about twice a week. The finish is going to take a beating over time but it seems to me that mechanically, the light is very nicely made. I don't think you will be disapointed with it, especially for the price.
Jeff

 

[Zackerty]

X5 bullet and waterproof
Q3 brighter and smaller

 

[ACMarina]

-brightness - QIII by a long shot. Uber-bright. .
-toughness - X5T, although the QIII is tough, the X5T is tougher. Especially in HAIII.
-size - QIII is small, X5T is a nice shape to carry, I think. .
-runtime - X5T. It'll light on batteries that won't power the QIII.

So it's 50-50. I'm never far enough from my spares to worry about runtime, so my EDC is the QIII. The X5T is always in my bag, though. .

 

[Hoya]

-brightness = Q3
-toughness =X5T
-size = Q3
-runtime =X5T

You be the judge.

 

[xpitxbullx]

Surefire E1E + KL4 using one R123.

Or is the options just between the Q-III and the X5T? If its just between them two, I think the Q-III is the best one.

 

[Blades]

Between the two, the QIII will be easier to carry. I would recommend taking a look at the Inova T1 also. It is what I have been EDCing for the last month. It works great for chasing mice. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif



Blades

 

[MaxaBaker]

Thanx for your answers guys /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif

Yes , I meant betwen the two listed. I don't think I could afford anything Surefire right now.

I think I'm leaning towards the QIII. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/thumbsup.gif

 

[wquiles]

The QIII due to the smaller size blends with almost anything you wear: dress pants, jeans, etc..

Will

PS: As soon as I find a Rechargable CR123 (the 4.2v type) I will be replacing my QIII by a VitalGear 1xcell with KL4 head /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif

 

[cratz2]

Well, I often have an X5T on me but the Q3 is pretty sweet as well. I really like the form factor and rugged feel of the X5T though I would probably slightly prefer a clickie and more throw. The X5T does many things well... Throwing light any kind of serious distance is not one of them. My LED_ASAP modded ARC AAA kills the X5T in throw while the Q3 would no doubt beat my ARC.

 

[redcar]

X5T - made in USA, lifetime warranty.

 

[Soundchaser]

I have not handled the X5, but I EDC the Q-III. The overall combination of qualities it provides is tough to beat, IMHO.

 

[diggdug13]

IMHO They are both great lights and EDCing either of them would be a good choice.. For me the best EDC is the TnC Keylux N cell beacause it's increadibly small so I can keep it in my pocket no matter what attire I'm in (suit, slacks or jeans) and it's incredibly bright with good battery life.

Doug

 

[Wrangler]

I own both of them and like both of them.
But I only EDC the Q3. The X5T is more of a backup light if a long runtime is requested. Imagine that the Inova is lacking in throw. But it`s very tough and a rugged feeling.
The magic cpf slogan: buy them both! /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/happy14.gif
Wolfgang
BTW the Inova T1 is a recommendable light too.