Re: Xtar S1 (3xXM-L, 3x18650) "Thrower" Review: RUNTIMES, VIDEO, BEAMSHOTS and more!
I've updated the main thread with results from my 4GREER 3100mAh battery (based on the Panasonic NCR18650A cell):
Basically, you get the exact same runtime profile as my Redilast 2900mAh cells on Max - just with an extra dozen or so minutes of runtime as the levels drops near the end.
I haven't bothered doing additional tests at the ~25% level, as it seems pretty clear there is no apparent circuit stabilization at the lower outputs (e.g., see HKJ's 40% and 6% voltage sweeps in his review).
As an aside, I appear to have confirmed my earlier supposition of excessive hum/whine being due to not making full contact with all three cells (i.e., hum disapppeared with further tightening of the tailcap). I have tried to measure the current draw on a single IMR-18650 cells at the lower outputs, and get extreme levels of whine/buzz at even the medium levels.
At around half max output, I measured current draw on single IMR-18650 to be just over 2.8A (EDIT: note that this reading is not accurate for a specific output, as the PWM and resistance in the DMM results in lower output and current when everything is connected). The whine was so severe at this level, I could feel the vibration through the handles of my multimeter leads. oo: At about a quarter max output, I measured 1.1A, and still had quite noticeable hum - but greatly attenuated (EDIT: again, these current readings are being affected by the resistance in the DMM).
As a result, I suspect my earlier speculation that an IMR26650 cell could work well in the light is unlikely. I don't have one to test, but you are likely to experience considerable whine if you try. Recommend you stick with 3x 18650 sources, as the manufacturer intended. :wave:
I've updated the main thread with results from my 4GREER 3100mAh battery (based on the Panasonic NCR18650A cell):
Basically, you get the exact same runtime profile as my Redilast 2900mAh cells on Max - just with an extra dozen or so minutes of runtime as the levels drops near the end.
I haven't bothered doing additional tests at the ~25% level, as it seems pretty clear there is no apparent circuit stabilization at the lower outputs (e.g., see HKJ's 40% and 6% voltage sweeps in his review).
As an aside, I appear to have confirmed my earlier supposition of excessive hum/whine being due to not making full contact with all three cells (i.e., hum disapppeared with further tightening of the tailcap). I have tried to measure the current draw on a single IMR-18650 cells at the lower outputs, and get extreme levels of whine/buzz at even the medium levels.
At around half max output, I measured current draw on single IMR-18650 to be just over 2.8A (EDIT: note that this reading is not accurate for a specific output, as the PWM and resistance in the DMM results in lower output and current when everything is connected). The whine was so severe at this level, I could feel the vibration through the handles of my multimeter leads. oo: At about a quarter max output, I measured 1.1A, and still had quite noticeable hum - but greatly attenuated (EDIT: again, these current readings are being affected by the resistance in the DMM).
As a result, I suspect my earlier speculation that an IMR26650 cell could work well in the light is unlikely. I don't have one to test, but you are likely to experience considerable whine if you try. Recommend you stick with 3x 18650 sources, as the manufacturer intended. :wave:
Last edited: