Dorcy Metal Gear and Fenix L1P comparison question

I have a Metal Gear and think the output is just perfect for my needs as a personal carry light, although its size doesn't make it the most practical for those purposes.

So I was wondering, does the Fenix L1P's output compare to or exceed the Metal Gear?
I realize I may lose some flood due to the smaller bezel of the Fenix.

Thanks for any info.

i like the output of the fenix better, it is a little more floody, the dorcy is a tighter beam and just a hair brighter than the fenix, more ringy , and more blue tint than the fenix, in fact given the larger spot of the fenix, the dorcy may indeed not be actually brighter, just tighter........here are some pic comparisons


fenix



dorcy metal gear






both reflectors


the dorcy is a good knock around light, the fenix is a great edc light for the pocket..........the dorcy sits on my nightstand, the fenix goes in my pocket where ever i go.

Great post, thanks! Just the info I needed.
I think my arm is twsited enough finally to take the plunge.