I thought the beam of the HDS I had was perfectly shaped. Right size of sidespill, right amount of light in the sidespill, right size spot, nice intensity in the spot. I don't have it anymore (although a U85 is in the future), and now I have a McLux III PD. The spot is a wee bit more concentrated than I'd prefer, but it's still good. The spot on the Fenix is way to concentrated for my tastes.
I don't care much for optics anymore. They throw nicely, but they suck for closer work. I need a balance.