I told myself I wasn't going to buy any CR123A lights, but I always had my eye on the
Dorcy Super 1 Watt. I regretted missing the Sears $20 sale on it a couple of months ago.
When I saw a Dorcy CR123A Super 1 watt flashlight for $20 a couple of days ago at Target, I relented and bought it. I like it so far, though there were a couple of minor factory quality control problems.
There was a small "ding" (spot of missing anodization) near the front bezel and an O-ring was misaligned when the bezel was screwed on at the factory. I removed the bezel, nudged the O-ring back in place, then reinstalled the bezel.
It is brighter and has a wider spill than my
Coast 1w 1AA LED Lenser David 15 (model 7840). My
2AA Mini Maglite with TerraLux TLE-5 drop in is brighter and has a wider spill. So the Dorcy's light is somewhere between those other two.
My wife has an
Eddie Bauer 3AAA 1 watt light resembling this Dorcy:
http://www.flashlightreviews.com/reviews/dorcy_luxeon.htm
Her
3AAA Eddie Bauer is brighter and the tint is whiter than my new CR123A Dorcy. Perhaps the
Luxeon lottery is at play here.
The
Dorcy Super 1 watt CR123A is attractive, feels solid, and I consider it a good value for the $20 I paid.
There is another review, with excellent photographs, at ImagoMetrics:
http://www.imagometrics.com/FLReviews/DRCY1W123.htm