I think I got it, it just needed a bit more solder on the neg lead to make good contact with ground.Works every time now!
4 cells is more than reccommended,but they seem to sag under load and its been fine for over a month, so far. I had been using 3 cells in another light and decided to step it up and see if it would hold, and it does. I was think of trying N cell but this is working ,and I have 20+ batteries for it.
The sleeve was covering all the cells,good idea.Ill have to keep an eye on that in the future.