After lurking in the background the past few months I have decided to post a thread.
First things first: I hate you guys! My problem: bad enough with the firearms, knives, camping/backpacking equipment - now it's flashlights. My wife doesn't understand. She sees me reading this forum and just shakes her head.
I do a lot of outdoor activities and live in a semi-rural area. After having owned several Mags of various sizes (and always being disappointed), I have begun a collection of sorts:
1) ARC AAA-P: A great little light I keep on my keyring. Very well-built with a solid feel. Surprisingly, it gets a lot of use. Excellent run-times!
2) Princeton Tec Apex: Being a camper and backpacker, a good headlamp is very important to me. This unit fits the bill perfectly with it's bright Luxeon III main light for general outdoor use and the 5mm LEDs for close up camp and in-tent use. Not cheap, but a nice upgrade over the old Petzl unit I "retired".
3) Photon Freedom: A surprisingly bright light in a small package. I don't use one myself (ARC AAA instead), but I bought several for my wife, daughters, and elderly father to keep on their keyrings. Very small and simple for them to use.
4) Inova X1: This light seems to be just perfect for so many uses such as inside power failures to walking the dog at night. Fantastic run time and a nice fit in the hand. I have one in each vehicle as well as one in my nightstand.
5) River Rock LED lantern: A great (and economical) light for backpacking and in-tent use. I own a few for camping and home power failures. Gave one to my dad as well.
6) Fenix L2P: A very nice 2AA light. I put a clip from an old AA Mag on it and carry it in my shirt pocket. Great for use at work when I am the last one to leave (much too frequently!) and I have to get something from another area of the building when the lights are off. I also love the clicky! Very good run-time for it's output.
7) Fenix P1: My newest addition - thanks to a great degree from all the feedback on this forum! A very powerful light for it's size but (IMO) not that much more output than my L2P. I just got it the other day and put a Duracell primary in it and took it out to the woods in back of my house for some general ("unscientific") comparison. As you can see I like AA and AAA batteries and am now wondering if this was a good addition. Very small for my hand and slower to operate than my L2P.
8) Streamlight ProPoly Luxeon 4AA: OK. This light has to be the best torch for the money. When I use it I often wonder why I really need any other lights (besides my ARC and Apex). For use at work I rely on it's safety ratings. A great size for general use with fantastic regulated runtimes. I have purchased several and keep them in the house, garage, and each vehicle. For me this has a good balance between flood and throw for use outside. I have also purchased several of them for others. When someone asks "what is a low cost light for general use", I always recommend the ProPoly.
9) Streamlight ProPoly Luxeon 3C: My standard outside emergency light. If I hear a noise outside/in the woods I grab this light (and my Glock 23). Also used for night hikes while camping. A bit more throw than the 4AA with longer runtimes. I love the belt clip and use it for general carry. Best of all with the ProPolys: no more "holes" ala Mag units!
I (and my wife) hope that's all for the time being, although the Surefire A2 always looms like a beacon (pun intended). And now that I have the P1 perhaps rechargeable 123s are an option. Time will tell.