I see "pocketable" or "truly pocketable" on CPF all the time but don't really know what it means to folks. A search did me no good. If not already done, why don't we CPF's propose a "standard" for pocketability. Who better that us? If this makes sense I will compile results from the responses and let's see where we end up.
Out of curiosity I found I could fit a large water bottle - 3" wide by 10" long - into the front pocket of all 3 pairs of pants I tried! However the top 4" is exposed, so 3" x 6" is the largest that can be pocketeted and not be visible. But no one would consider 3 x 10 or 3 x 6 either to be pocketable, right?
"Comfortable" pocketability for me means that I can put the light in my pocket (let's say with no other items) and through the day and my normal tasks walking/sitting/etc., I do not really notice or get distracted by it. Based on my experience that limit is found no greater than 1" diameter and 3.5" height (25mm x 90mm) - and that's on the edge for me - just starting to get a little annoying
. This is basically the size of the HDS EDC lights. I notice a distinct and clear improvement when it gets to 0.8" x 2.5" (20mm x 65mm) - such as the FF3 or the Fexix P1 - and I think that's more where I'd put the target for "comfortable"
. (And the truth is only my Raw Ns at 0.7" x 1.8" or 18mm x 45mm is really incognito
- but that's a bit too far I think for our purposes).
Somehow I think I'm a little more sensitive than most to the size thing. What do you find the preferred (comfortable/not noticable) size and the maximum size (on the edge of annoyance) for pocketability to be?
Out of curiosity I found I could fit a large water bottle - 3" wide by 10" long - into the front pocket of all 3 pairs of pants I tried! However the top 4" is exposed, so 3" x 6" is the largest that can be pocketeted and not be visible. But no one would consider 3 x 10 or 3 x 6 either to be pocketable, right?
"Comfortable" pocketability for me means that I can put the light in my pocket (let's say with no other items) and through the day and my normal tasks walking/sitting/etc., I do not really notice or get distracted by it. Based on my experience that limit is found no greater than 1" diameter and 3.5" height (25mm x 90mm) - and that's on the edge for me - just starting to get a little annoying
Somehow I think I'm a little more sensitive than most to the size thing. What do you find the preferred (comfortable/not noticable) size and the maximum size (on the edge of annoyance) for pocketability to be?
Last edited: