I'm going to try the bulb first using modded stock reflectors to get help get an idea, but I was wondering what you guys like. What's the closest to a Surefire with that bulb? Probably want just enough to kill the artifacts.
I use the M@G stock reflector on my ROP low. It is terrific and focuses well.
That being said, I have a fivemega dual function cammed metal reflector on the ready line. Check out the "group buys and passarounds" sub-forum via the forum jump at the bottom of the page.
I too normally use a smooth stock reflector, although I have a Med. orange peel, that's closer to a Light peel. It smooths the beam out a bit more, but I do notice the loss in throw. I've also found with my particular ROP low bulb the globe isn't centered in the base.
Run-time test (my first): ROP high bulb 2D with 6 AA NiMHs Borofloat lens and stock reflector: After being on and hand held for 5 minutes, indoors temp approx 65F, silver coating bubbles nearest bulb about 1/8 inch ring and blue plastic is hot but can be handled.
Brilliant expose of the stock reflector. Concise verbage, clear pictures and quite interesting. Appreciate your taking it to failure. Thank you kindly.
I continue to use the stock reflectors in my one hotwire that doesn't have a metal reflector until I can replace it with a cammed MOP, medium orange peel, next year when fivemega has more available. Something to look forward to.
I was thinking maybe MOP too. I'm not sure if the low ROP puts out enough to go to a heavier stippling. I made some up some of the stock reflectors with a medium heavier stippling last night and I'll see what that low ROP likes. Maybe if I post up some pics we could discuss it more.
I have a MOP in the ROP low, which smooths it out a bit whilst still retaining good throw. In my Mag85 I'm using a LS, as the MOP doesn't smooth it out enough.