Protected vs. Unprotected 18650's

martonic

Enlightened
Joined
Oct 15, 2006
Messages
319
What are the pros and cons of protected vs. unprotected 18650's?

Some lights specify "unprotected 18650". Why will protected cells not work in these lights?

What extra precautions are needed to use those "unprotected" cells?
 

ROVER

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Oct 7, 2005
Messages
194
Protected cells have a circuit that protects the battery from over charging, over discharging, and getting too hot. If something bad happens, the circuit opens--and you'll see zero volts across the battery till it's plugged in a charger. These are what you want.

Unprotected cells are just raw batteries. In lithium batteries, this is good for people who know what they are doing and are trying to push the envelope as far as super high discharge. To the average Joe, this can result in fires or even batteries exploding so violently, they burst your flashlight. If you have to ask--stick to protected cells.
 

greenLED

Flashaholic
Joined
Mar 26, 2004
Messages
13,263
Location
La Tiquicia
If you are into "hotwires", be aware that some protected cells won't power some super-lamps that people use (too much current).
 

mdocod

Flashaholic
Joined
Nov 9, 2005
Messages
7,544
Location
COLORado spRINGs
to elaborate on what GreenLED said.....

Some protected cells have very basic current limits set on them... If the cells were intended to be used in slow drain applications like a laptop or LED light, then there may or may not be a very high current threshold... For example: I bought some 17500 size cells awhile back from a source I won't mentioned at this time... they are great cells that live up to their capacity rating very well, however, they will not deliver any more than about 1.3amp without going open circuit... good for LED lights, terrible for incandescent lights...

Then there are cells like the ones Wolf-Eyes, Pila, And AW (dealer section) sell.. these are protected cells, that have higher than normal current limit settings... In some cases, the protection circuit is actually set to allow current higher than would actually be safe for continual discharge of the cells... This is done so that these cells can light up big superbulbs that have an initial "current spike" while the filament warms up(all bulbs have this behavior, but the bigger the filament, the bigger the current spike)- Of course, it becomes the users responsibility to choose a load that is appropriate for the cells. The protection circuits in cells like this are there more to prevent short circuit conditions, and overcharge/discharge.


[edit in] then of course, there are time bombs I call unprotected cells...
Well... actually.. as long as the user is careful never to short circuit these or work them way too hard, there is a good chance there will never be incident.. The trouble is when they are discharged too far, the discharging too much goes smoothly. but then the unsuspecting user puts the over-discharged cells on the charger, and a few hours later, the living room is filled with toxic gases and chemical fire.
 
Last edited:
Top