How about a high quality LED reading light?

Al_Havemann

Enlightened
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Messages
302
Location
New York City
Has anyone thought about building a good led based reading lamp? I'm not talking about a flashlight or those little battery lamps, what I need is a really high quality floor lamp for reading (and my wife hates floor lamps).

Here's what I have in mind.

A Cree (or multiple maybe?) based, adjustable height floor lamp with a goose neck or something to allow precise, "over the shoulder", positioning. It needs to be AC powered and preferably have a lens or other method of focusing that tightly floods an 18-20 inch area at a distance of 3 feet without artifacts that would interfere with reading.

It would be ideal if the focus could be adjusted as needed, maybe with a sliding hood or something. The height should adjust enough that it can be dropped behind a recliner when not in use and the goose neck long and stiff enough to allow positioning without sag. It should also be rugged and break down for traveling.

Since my eyes have a lot of age in them, it needs to be really bright; preferably the page should be illuminated like outdoors on a bright, but slightly overcast day. I've found that with this much light on a page I'm able to read comfortably for long periods without much of the usual eye strain.

I built a lamp like this a while back and it turned out well enough that I know this design has the potential to be a great reading light if it was built by a pro (which I'm not).

I used a microphone stand with a 16" goose neck and fitted a home made head holding a Luxeon V. I used a commercial buck circuit that's fed from a 12v DC wall wart. The booster holds the Lux V at near maximum output of about 120 lumen's. This worked out reasonably well as a proof of concept, but it really needs a means of focusing and far better construction, in other words, professional design and execution.

The Lux V gets hot over time despite extensive heat sinking, which leads me to believe a Cree, or multiple Crees would be better suited for the job, although I have to admit that even with hundreds of hot running hours on it, the LuxV it hasn't missed a beat. I depend on it despite my wife's opinion that it's "probably the ugliest thing she's ever seen" (and she's right, it is).

Even though it's crudely built, it's much better for reading than a $200.00 floor lamp I bought that uses a 55 watt CF tube. Not that the Led lamp is brighter than the CF, it's not; but because of its narrow, even illumination and the very precise positioning, it doesn't have any glare, bright spots or shadows. The amount of illumination is adequate but I'd prefer a lot more, even better would be adjustable output.

It's just a thought since I haven't had any luck finding what I need, that maybe some of you who really have the know-how and machining capability might consider the possibility of designing and manufacturing such a lamp.

Consider that there's a big market here, age has its way, like it or not. More than just the narrow market of a bunch of flashlight aficionado's (not that there's anything wrong with that!), but the very real possibility of a much broader market of people who really like to read and would buy a lamp that is expressly designed for that specific purpose by a pro. One that puts the noon time sun right on a page of a book without shadows or glare.

I've paid over $200.00 for reading lights in the past and I'd pay more for a really good, tightly designed and executed light with those capabilities

Think about it.

Al
 

FrogsInWinter

Enlightened
Joined
Feb 27, 2006
Messages
370
Location
NYC
Have you heard about the Lightwedge by any chance?

http://www.lightwedge.com/

I gave two of these as a Christmas gift to a friend of mine who is an avid reader. Only downside is that based on your post, it might not be as bright as you would like.
 

2xTrinity

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
2,386
Location
California
A Cree (or multiple maybe?) based, adjustable height floor lamp with a goose neck or something to allow precise, "over the shoulder", positioning. It needs to be AC powered and preferably have a lens or other method of focusing that tightly floods an 18-20 inch area at a distance of 3 feet without artifacts that would interfere with reading.
I have a very kludgy Cree-based reading light -- it's essntially just a Cree LED attached to an old small flashlight tube as a heatsink with the reflector removed -- I simply soldered a switching powersupply from a cell phone charger directly to the LED, which runs the LED at 400mA regulated from the wall. I simply set the light down on my body when reading in a reclined position and the bare emitter lights the page nicely with a wide, even flood beam. I'm looking into getting an incandescent reading lamp with adjustable head, and simply swapping the bulb for a Cree and wiring in a cell phone power supply to make an awesome reading lamp for cheap. The fact that those run a lot cooler than incan/halogen based lamps is a major advantage, also, I find the cool white light gives better contrast for reading technical books with diagrams etc. than standard incandescent lamps.

For a reading lamp in my opinion, the Cree's inherent beam pattern is close to perfect -- just a shade to prevent direct glare is really all that's needed. A wide flood is ideal, so that everything is lit evenly. the fact that it lights up some of the space around the book is actually an advantage IMO, if you want to say read, and take notes with a notepad at the same time.
 
Last edited:

2xTrinity

Flashlight Enthusiast
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
2,386
Location
California
GeorgePaul said:
Take a look here. Not a floor lamp, not a Cree, but maybe you can use it for something.
This is the sort of thing I was thinking about making. Performing an emitter swap on this would bump the lumens up from ~25-30, to around 60 at the same power consumption. It would also bump the price up from ~$35, to about $42 plus time (Assuming $7 shipped for a Seoul emitter from DX). I'm probably getting about 100 out of my 400mA cree though and that's a little on the high side for reading (though it's not as bad as it lights up the surroundings around the book as well, so the eyes adjust to the intensity better)
 

ksonger

Newly Enlightened
Joined
Dec 30, 2006
Messages
75
how about something like this? This is for an mr16 base (12v i believe) i have one with a standard screw base 110v coming to try out. I have the cool white version, most likely too bright for reading light but still very nice. i have a wholesale list from these guys, i would love to see them pan out and go around replaceing my bulbs
http://cgi.ebay.com/3-x-1W-MR16-CRE...085522847QQcategoryZ20706QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

ken
 
Top