I know you're kidding, but good point!
Bottom line for me is that HAIII is so highly touted by every manufacturer of the lights we talk about on this forum, that one is led to believe HAIII is actually tougher than it really is. It's certainly hyped on Surefire's website... Therefore, when I inserted my new M3-CB into my brand new SF V71 holster for the first time and it put a nice big scratch on my light; I was pissed.
As far as the argument that these lights are made to be used, etc... that's fine. Nevertheless, being scratched by its own holster specifically designed for it? Nope! Definitely a let down. So when I read all the other marketing material from Surefire, I have to take it with a grain of salt. Moreover, for a product that is touted as the best of the best by many folks, again my scratch experience was a real let down.
With all of the above said, Surefire did make it right by sending me a new head for my M3-CB. I removed the steel springs from the inside of the holster - no more scratches and holster holds fine.