I just got it working guys though still flaky. I took a step back and looked at how a yellow plastic 2D Rayovac worked. I saw that the switch that you push up and down actually pushed a strip of copper up and down the entire flashlight. When you turned it on that strip would move and connect to the metal reflector. Until this happened though, the positive end of the battery was always in contact with the bulb holder. On the B-Lite, there was no strip moving up and down, but two little pieces where one would be pushed onto the other. That's the switch. From there was a strip of copper about 3 inches long that was screwed to the switch which was always in contact with the metal reflector. When you push up on the switch, the actual pushing motion makes the two little pieces of copper in the switch touch. That turns on the light. Again, the positive end of the battery was always connected to the bulb holder. The way I had it was the long 3 inch strip was touching the positive end of the battery as well as touching the bulb holder. Not a good thing. Like I said before, things are still a bit flaky, but I think I can get it working fine. I'll probably replace the current bulb with a LED drop in. I might also polish the reflector (depending on what metal it is) and replace the lens. The lens is, well, horrible plastic that's yellowed slightly with time.
