Sunlight is 6500K, which should be Luxeon W0, SSC SW0, and Cree WD.
Personally, I like something one bin cooler, i.e. Luxeon X0, SSC SXO, and Cree WC - but that's just me. Others like warmer bins because they look like incans - I really don't understand that logic...but to each his own. I would think something closer to the color of sunlight would be best - and I like the cooler tints for that wow effect of the LED in general (much like I enjoy the blue tint of HID).
Regarding the difference between P4 and Q2 - not much of a difference overall - especially at baseline (@350mA, only 6.5 lumens I think)...but some people are really caught up on numbers. You wouldn't notice the difference unless they were both at higher currents side by side (as the currents go up, the difference increases). You can look for my posts around here for all of the bin info of the Crees P4 - R4 at baseline (i.e. 350mA), 750mA (which is 180% brighter then baseline), and 1000mA (which is 220% brighter then baseline). If you're interested, I've also estimated from Cree's datasheet that 875mA is 200% brighter then their baseline rated output.