P1DCE or P2DCE

I have read the specs. on these two but cant make up my mind.
I like the push button but it's larger than the twisty.

Is there a clear winner between these two?

Please help me decide.

I plan to get one of these as well as an L1DCE.

We've had 2 or 3 threads about that exact same comparison, maybe you can use the search function to find them you will find valuable information there.

Luigi

May depend on how you want to carry them. I like using the holster so the size between the two made no real difference for me. I started with the P1D-CE, but after getting a P3D-CE and liking the interface I knew the P2D-CE would be the perfect combination of size and function. I kinda grew tired of having to twist and twist to adjust modes. The P2D-CE can start in low, or turbo, depending on if you have the bezel tight or loose. I prefer the clicky and I have had no problems with it.

If you want a keychain light or pocket light, you may prefer the smaller size of the P1D-CE.

i prefer the UI of P1D CE

with a clickie body, i can cycle through all the modes with 1 hand

but ... P1D CE's low is too high and getting clickie is not cheap